@TNMP had 2 gas facilities registered as critical infrastructure before the storm. Now has 177. This really is stunning. They're a small player but have a significant Permian footprint. #txlege#txenergy#TexasBlackouts
Liz Jones of @oncor asks the @PUCTX for clarification on the load management section of SB3. Not clear if that fits within current #energyefficiency programs or somehow exists outside of them. She's speaking of this in Section 16 #txlege#txenergy
First speaker Warren Lasher, System Planning at @ERCOT_ISO
Very interesting slide from @ERCOT_ISO's Warren Lasher. Oil and gas production and processing in the Permian is driving reliability problems and the boom and bust nature of the business makes building transmission to the Permian very difficult.
Note that S. TX is challenged both for export of #wind and #solar & import for reliability when generation is below expected. DFW & Houston are both economic & reliability needs driven by huge population growth. W TX has economic need to get more cheap generation to load centers.
Wayman Smith of @AEPTexas says that the variability of demand (see the green line) is driven by resistance heating.
My words not his: #energyefficiency would help with this!!! If you're only talking about supply, you're only dealing with half the problem!
Asked by commissioners will we have a problem, Smith says much of that depends on demand. Reminder that #energyefficiency programs to replace resistance heat with highly efficient heat pumps can happen very quickly. Transmission takes 6-8 years. Need both, not an either/or.
Sharyland Utilities raising issue that #SB1281 which should speed up much needed transmission isn't due for rulemaking by the @PUCTX until June 2022 with ERCOT implementation after that. Meanwhile transmission constraints limit generation that needs to move in or out of the #RGV.
Finally, Warren Lasher makes the point that insufficient transmission means #renewables trapped in the #RGV without access to other parts of the state drive prices lower, reducing incentive for new generation of all kinds. #txlege#txenergy
Lasher says that #sb1281 requires a look at improving reliability in extreme weather scenarios and says ERCOT will recommend a new reliability line further connecting the #RGV to the rest of the state. Will take ~6 years to get done. #txlege#transmission
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Starting now. After brief opening statement by Chair Schwertner. Sen @whitmire_john asks why do we have to incentivize power plants to do what they're supposed to? Sen Nichols says they're profit seeking companies and they won't invest unless they can make money.
Whitmire responds: are you talking about providing government subsidies for gas generation? Tells Nichols he's sounding like the Biden Administration. Not sure why we would throw incentives at thermal generation.
There are big changes coming to #ERCOT. Are they the right changes? Are they enough? And what do we know about it so far? @PUCTX and @ERCOT_ISO held a press conference today. Some thoughts on the presser and other recent events below. #txlege#txenergy 1/ statesman.com/story/news/202…
Been a busy month: The presser today, along with a 7/1 PUC work session and 7/13 Senate hearing, And another @PUCTX workshop this Monday on transmission planning and how rotating outages/load shedding are done. Agenda & presentations were posted today 2/ interchange.puc.texas.gov/Documents/5226…
Additionally, the ERCOT Roadmap with 60 action items (aka the 60 points of light) was released last week plus @EnergyUT's report on causes of the Feb outages. Whew. 3/
Does anyone have an update to the @TXAG investigation of price gouging? Four months ago, the AG said: "I am expanding the scope of my investigation to include the natural gas industry." Are there any results from this investigation? #txlege#txenergy 1/ texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/…
Section 17.46(b)(27) of the Bus. & Comm. Code defines deceptive trade practices to include: "(A) selling or leasing fuel... at an exorbitant or excessive price; or (B) demanding an exorbitant or excessive price in connection with the sale...of fuel..." 2/ statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC…
Natural gas prices were 100-300x normal prices in Feb. I don't know whether that meets the legal standard for price gouging but it's worth discussing. Look at this tweet and the next couple from a House hearing following the storms #txlege#txenergy 3/
Texas' energy woes will persist, and costs will be higher, unless demand side resources like #energyefficiency and #demandresponse, #solar and #storage, are deployed at scale. Alison Siverstein wrote a great piece in @UtilityDive about this. A quick 🧵
Silverstein is a former FERC & PUC staffer w/ decades of energy experience. She wrote that Texas policymakers and the @PUCTX and @ERCOT_ISO need to "shore up grid reliability by aggressively managing electricity demand, not just throwing money at supply-side measures." #txenergy
She writes that over the last decade TX population increased 16% while energy use increased 20%. Much of that increase is driven by inefficient homes & buildings. We have #energyefficiency programs in Texas that deliver savings at 1 penny per kWh. Try to buy energy for that!
Chairman Lake says the meeting today is a venue for discussion, a forum for consideration of ideas, not for taking action, which will stay in the more formal open meetings.
Commissioner McAdams agrees that this is a good way to discuss things before decisions are made which gives the public more chance to weigh in.
Public comment begins.
Rita Robles, a resident of Denver Harbor, a Houston neighborhood, addresses the commissioners. Says many people in her neighborhood had busted pipes. One neighbor still hasn't been able to fix her pipes nearly four months later.
Patrick says he will only work on these things if we're helping ratepayers. Great.
He's indignant about House not taking ratepayer assistance program which was only brought up in the last few days. It's been 100 days since the storm. Where was this proposal in April/early May?
It makes sense to help ratepayers. The Senate had #SB243 to increase #energyefficiency programs which helps customers to save money AND make their homes more resilient. Never got out of committee. The House had #HB3460, the Power Act, to give direct payments to Texans