Chandrachud J points out that data is to be archived for five years.
(This discussion is around the Aadhaar authentication regulations).
Chandrachud J says that distinction may not be persuasive, because in today's world, you have only notional consent even with respect to private players.
KS says, "how can this ever be a money bill."
Chandrachud J says that that link comes from the Consolidated Fund of India.
Sibal says that Chidambaram knows more about money than he does.
Chandrachud J says that you can't judge the validity of an act by the potential for abuse.
KS says that this is about how much power you are giving up to the State.
Chandrachud J repeats the point that the constitutionality of a law has to be judged on the generality of cases and not on exceptional cases.