Writing this so that we remember that our forms of resistance must be as varied and diverse as the forms of exclusion we face. The courage of today's protestors deserves pathways tomorrow to grow and sustain.
The making of a list itself delegitimises citizenship even if no one ever acts on it, even if hypothetically everyone "passes," because the NRC shifts the onus on proving citizenship onto the citizen and away from the state.
Second, there is no evidence that any state capacity exists to be able to do an NRC without error rates of 20-40%. Aadhar/PDS show this. Three implications:
Our resistance must play the long game, and must play all its registers from protest to civil disobedience to bureaucratic undoing. Each will require struggle, but, crucially, in different forms.