(1/22) Our new paper @NatureEnergyJnl (rdcu.be/cikbq) proposes a solution to break the deadlock in negotiations between #Ethiopia 🇪🇹, #Sudan 🇸🇩 & #Egypt 🇪🇬 on the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (#GERD) on the #BlueNile – with help of #solar and #wind power. Thread👇 Image
(2/22) The #BlueNile (Abay) is highly seasonal, with extreme differences in flow between dry and wet months. #GERD’s reservoir is so large it can store the full annual flow & deliver #hydropower at a stable rate throughout the year - suppressing the river flow #seasonality. Image
(3/22) Delivering hydropower w/o seasonality makes loads of sense from Ethiopian perspective, but overhauls natural timing of water reaching #Sudan & #Egypt. Behind many disagreements on #GERD lies downstream countries’ fear of s/o upstream having control over #BlueNile flow… Image
(4/22) What have #solar & #wind power (VRE: variable renewables) got to do with this? Like river flow, the region's sunshine & winds, too, are highly seasonal. But here’s the point: their profile is OPPOSITE to that of river flow. In 🇪🇹🇸🇩 VRE is strongest during the DRY season. Image
(5/22) Hydro plants like #GERD can be used flexibly to "firm up" intermittent VRE year-round, 24/7. What if GERD were operated in this way? Given the seasonality of VRE in the region, GERD #hydropower production would have to be relatively low in dry season, high in wet season.
(6/22) We design 4 scenarios to showcase what this would mean for GERD outflow: S1 (GERD operated independently of VRE), S2 (GERD operated w/ VRE in 🇪🇹), S3 (GERD operated w/ VRE in 🇪🇹+🇸🇩), and S4 (same as S3, but w/ so much VRE that full range of GERD flexibility needed). Image
(7/22) Now, the crucial point: This would *reintroduce* #seasonality in #GERD outflow, mimicking natural pattern. Without VRE this would make no sense (since ETH power demand isn't very seasonal, cf. S1) - but w/ lots of VRE (S2-S4), it’s a very logical approach to operating GERD Image
(8/22) What would that mean for 🇸🇩🇪🇬? While #Ethiopia would have all benefits of a big dam, for #Sudan+#Egypt, it would look as if Ethiopia only built a modest, relatively small reservoir. Many such reservoirs already exist on the #Nile, whose presence is uncontested. Image
(9/22) Interestingly, this works BETTER in a joint Power Pool w/ countries trading electricity. E.g. VRE in Sudan is a better complement to GERD’s hydro than VRE in Ethiopia. Hence, there are mutually beneficial links between the sharing of #energy resources & #water resources. Image
(10/22) Next to increasing VRE penetration and reducing downstream objections to GERD operation, synergetic GERD-VRE operation has various other benefits - e.g. it improves compliance w/ environmental flows in Sudan, while still protecting Sudan from extreme droughts and floods. Image
(11/22) Synergetic GERD-VRE operation would also dispel any allegations that #GERD is "oversized" – the alleged oversizing actually becomes an asset for #Ethiopia with increasing VRE infeed, because VRE benefits from the high “operating reserve” of GERD. Image
(12/22) Further, by retaining seasonality in #BlueNile flow, the timing of water reaching #Egypt’s High Aswan Dam (HAD) wouldn't be drastically overhauled - so there won't be prolonged periods in which #GERD fills up while #HAD empties, thus assuaging Egypt’s anxiety over GERD. Image
(13/22) Our simulations cover 26 years of river flow, and thus contain information on extremely dry years as well. Under all scenarios, GERD can mitigate the extremes in natural flow. Egypt+Sudan will benefit from GERD by receiving more water during dry years than previously. Image
(14/22) What does this mean for the ongoing talks around a tripartite agreement for GERD operation? We suggest that such an agreement could be centered on *energy*, not *water* objectives - eg Ethiopia operating GERD in synergy w/ large VRE fleet in Eastern Africa Power Pool
(15/22) Given all of the above, such an agreement would reassure Egypt+Sudan that GERD does no harm; meanwhile, as Ethiopia wishes, it would decouple GERD talks from overall water sharing issues, bc agreement would be centered on energy, not water.
(16/22) If #Ethiopia pursued similar operational schemes for its other #hydropower plants, it could integrate massive amounts of #solar and #wind power on its electricity grid, diversifying its power mix. ETH power generation by 2030 could be nearly 50% #VRE. Image
(17/22) On the long term, this will help Ethiopia lower electricity costs. Thanks to ever-plummeting #solar & #wind power costs, the time that these will become cheaper than #hydropower is fast approaching. Sudan, too, would benefit - displacing #fossilfuels with hydro-firmed VRE Image
(18/22) At the same time as VRE costs are plummeting, massive #hydropower projects are falling out of favour with international donors, and the #ParisAgreement strongly discourages new #fossilfuel investments. Our proposed solution fits well into these worldwide trends.
(19/22) In summary: To support the ongoing #GERD negotiations between #Ethiopia, #Sudan & #Egypt, we call for integrated hydro-solar-wind planning to be taken up in the talks as soon as possible. It could be a win-win-win-win-win situation for the region. Image
(21/22) Finally, big thanks to co-authors Dalia Fadly (@KU_Leuven), Stefan Liersch, Hagen Koch (both @PIK_Climate), @WimThiery (@VUBrussel), and an anonymous Ethiopian fellow researcher for inspiring discussions and great collaboration.
(22/22) Link to article: nature.com/articles/s4156…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sebastian Sterl

Sebastian Sterl Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!