not coopting far right (13): 🇨🇾🇪🇪🇩🇪🇮🇪🇱🇻🇱🇹🇱🇺🇲🇹🇵🇹🇷🇴🇪🇸🇸🇪
As I argue in "The Far Right Today", boundaries have become porous and categorization is difficult.
1. This is bit different from yesterday's Tweet.
- I mixed up parties in Estonia ☺️
- I think ND in Greece should be in coopters, because several of high-ranking "former" far-right politicians.
- I continue to struggle with Tories (see next tweet).
2. Tories are, like Republican Party, example of conservative party that behaves increasingly like far right party. Is it ideological change or tactical opportunism? Difficult to say. In case of Fidesz and PiS it turned to be first... Where is the exact boundary?
3. Academics, journalists, and politicians are very conservative in their terminology. We are very hesitant to change categorizations, particularly from good/neutral to negative -- and conservative parties have "reputational shield".
4. The "party family" is incredibly dominant concept in comparative politics, implicitly more than explicitly, but it is theoretically underdeveloped and empirically almost ignored. We also seem to assume stability over change in terms of classifications.
5. These are the biggest parties in the polls, not necessarily parties in governments. Several countries have biggest far right party, which has never been in govt, or biggest party not far right (coopter) but far right has been in govt.
6. What this list shows, more than anything, is that
- far right parties have become major players in Europe.
- far right ideas and actors have been mainstreamed and normalized
- but there is still lot of diversity.
7. I really wish there was more substantial research into party ideologies. Sure, party positions in manifestoes or "expert studies" are insightful, but ideology is much more than issue positions.
8. While there is quite a lot of research on far-right ideology as well as ideology of far right parties, this is not case for most other party families -- not even the big, traditional ones (e.f. CD, SD, liberal).
9. There is painfully little research on the ideology of conservatism, let alone the ideology of conservative parties, particularly in Europe.
10. All to say that we should take ideology more important in party studies and we should take parties more important in ideology studies and that much has been changing in the past two decades. #TheEnd
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1. Except for race, the crowd is incredibly diverse -- age, education, far-right subculture, region, even gender (although less so those inside the Capitol).
2. The media does a disservice to understanding of far right and its threat by primarily using pictures of faceless mobs or of exceptional people -- notably the "QAnon Shaman". Many are people like your (and definitely my) neighbors and students (or their parents).
I'm going with the experts. #Georgia did it... again!
I'm not an expert on Georgia politics, but simply living here for almost 10 years makes me more of an expert than 95% of pundits in national media, so here is quick #thread
1. This is a victory for African American grassroots campaigning. Sure, @staceyabrams has been amazing, but many, many others have been too.
2. African Americans have come through big for Georgia, and thereby the US. They finally deserve the credit, not just as "followers" but as LEADERS of Democratic politics.
There are lot of received wisdoms about #FarRight (often wrongly referred to as #populism ) and #COVID19 so @JakubWondreys and I looked into it. Turns out, shocker, most are wrong.
Below is link to Open Access article. Main points in #thread
1. We focused exclusively on main far right parties in Europe and on the first wave. However, recent update shows that little has changed.
2. First, we looked into stereotype that "populists" (i.e. far right) ignores or minimizes COVID-19. This is almost exclusively based on Bolsonaro and Trump, who turn out to be exceptions rather than rule.
1. Even before Biden was crowned "president-elect" the different sides opened up the power struggle. Progressives mainly through social media, centrists mainly through traditional media.
2. Progressives argued that they had increased turnout, including in swing states (eg Omar in MN), and thereby won Biden the election.
As we are starting to analyze and assess the Trump presidency, we should also start analyzing our own coverage of it, both academic and journalistic.
Much was predicted that didn't come true and much came true that wasn't predicted.
And, yes, I said "we". 👈
For example, until COVID-19 really hit, I thought Trump was going to be re-elected (again lose popular vote but win EC). Until November 3 I thought Biden would win in landslide but worried Trump would sneak out an EC win. 1/2