So apparently we are now doing the "Actually, Germany is pretty good and this is all the evil Poles' and Britts' doing". I will disagree.
To begin with, yes, there is a some of truth to the fact that #Germany has done more when it comes to supporting #Ukraine then they get credit for. In particular on the air defence side of things, the Gepards and IRIS-T have made a real impact, to take the obvious example.
It's also correct that no *formal* request for transfer of #Leopard2 has been made, and that while many countries agree that "someone" should give Ukraine Leopards, significantly fewer are happy to provide theirs.
The big issue here is obviously that most countries have as many tanks as they feel they need, meaning those with many feel they need many, and those who could give away tanks have few to give. I discussed this recently from a Finnish POV. corporalfrisk.com/2023/01/15/fre…
It's also true that Polish political leadership at times is, let's say, trigger-happy when it comes to making grand statements, and sometimes reality has a tendency to come back for a second round.
It's also entirely possible that parts of the British media landscape is all too happy to bash Germany for anything bad in the world.
However, all this is just part of the picture. And when you look at the whole picture, it isn't particularly rosy for Germany.
Germany has consistently been dragging their feet every step of the way. When countries like #UK, #Estonia, and #Poland were already shipping missiles to #Ukraine, Germany was still thinking. When Poland was already shipping tanks to Ukraine, Germany was busy feet dragging.
The "no formal request"-argument is moot at best and dishonest at worst. It's pretty much standard practice to not ask countries for permission if you know that the answer will be "No" (same btw often goes for formal applications for industry export licenses).
And let's not kid ourselves, #Scholz has made it clear Germany won't greenlight a transfer of the Leopard without US supplying the #Abrams. Abrams is certainly a great tank, but it's more thirsty and more maintenance-heavy. sueddeutsche.de/politik/ukrain…
Would it still be a useable tank? Certainly, but calling out the US for not doing enough is not something that's grounded in the numbers. Under the current conditions, the #Leopard *is* the one making more sense, and would provide Europe with an opportunity to step up. 
It's also extremely hard to make a serious argument for "keine alleingänge" when quite the number of countries have been supporting sending Leopards, and the UK is shipping the best tank they've got (in limited numbers, as #Challenger2 does not make sense in the long run).
As I said before, I do believe that Scholz thinks he is making the right choices. That still doesn't make it so, and for everything Germany is in fact doing, it is still the main villain in the story about when and how to #FreeTheLeopards.
https://twitter.com/CorporalFrisk/status/1615993702895206402?s=20&t=R5RHnttbt68ta8LBLtt74Q
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
