Erik Zimerman Profile picture
May 16 11 tweets 6 min read
Update. After an operational pause to regroup and resupply after a massive artillery expenditure, #Russian forces continue their advance on the #Lysychansk cauldron. The series of events on #SiverskyiDonets crossings is complex & still unclear. Starting with the bridge revealed
revealed by #CNN (which I geolocated upon release) UA forces had success destroying several RU pontoon bridges. The latest video they released however, which was meant to show a RU vehicle drowning in the river, showed a third bridge still standing. Reports were received of the
forces that had crossed near Bilohorivka moving northeast towards Pryvillia. UA forces can still not move near the bank in many locations, though a couple of images were released of a UA reporter at the southern extreme of Bilohorivka where UA still hold the high ground.
The advance from the south in the #Popasna area is much clearer. RU forces are passed Oleksandropillia & the Viktorivka area along the main road. Fighting is now at the critical hub of #Vrubivka. RU forces are also likely to advance along the railway towards Berestove to cut off
the T1302 highway which is the Bakhmut - Lysychansk road. Shelling has resumed in the north in the critical junction areas of Siversk and near Zolotarivka & Topolivka. Other forces advancing from the east, likely including #Chechen forces which recently finished clearing #Nyzhnie
are advancing westward to cut off the T103 road to Lysychansk & Severodonetsk. Additional forces continue to advance on Zolote from Berezivske / Holubivka. Referring to the first thread image RU forces are poised to soon control both junctions in red. Taking either the green &/or
both blue circled junctions would cut off the Lysychansk cauldron and connected salients. However, even seizing the 2 former (red) & cutting off the T1302 road which can all be done from the #Popasna front, would severely cut off the salient as the northern supply routes through
Siversk are within artillery range of the northern RU forces, even if from the northern bank of the Siverskyi Donets. #Ukrainian forces made a very large effort to stop RU advance from the north & across the river. However, in doing so they have allowed an easy advance from
#Popasna & the south, where no large river crossing is needed at all & the Russian supply lines are easy to extend, with Popasna itself being an important rail hub. #Ukrainian forces had to either stop both pincers, or outmaneuver them. For example letting one seemingly advance
only to find itself isolated & cut off. This was possible by allowing the RU forces a narrow corridor of advance along a chosen route, where concentrated forces could spring the ambush.
We have not seen #Ukrainian field forces capable of such maneuvers yet, and they have not shown them here either, rather epitomizing what Frederik the Great meant, when he told us that he who defends everything defends nothing.

#RussiaUkraineWar

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Erik Zimerman

Erik Zimerman Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ZimermanErik

May 17
Finally, #Zelensky has ordered, or likely more accurately been forced to accept, the surrender of the men who refuse to go on dying for his ego. As I wrote more than once, had it not been for their recent use of human shields to extend the lifespan of the #Azovstl siege, and the Image
endless begging for the world to save them (much more from Serhyi Volyna & others than #Azov's Denys "Redis" Prokopenko), then they could have come out to the salute & applause of their Russian foes. Their more recent actions were a stain on the honor of their brave stand. ImageImage
Ironically, but not surprisingly, this more shameful period is when the world media has lionized & even idolized them much more. As I noted recently, this would only serve to increase the PR value of the soon-to-be POWs held by #Russia. Image
Read 14 tweets
May 15
Being a slow news day as far as info from the critical fronts, want to discuss an event from some days back. #Ukrainian sources released this drone video, claiming it shows a #Russian helicopter being destroyed on #SnakeIsland. Have wanted to discuss since I became aware of it on
May 8. For ~1 week, UA forces targeted #SnakeIsland (or nicer, Serpent Island, of ancient #Achilles lore) with a puzzling amount of air assets. As I reported then, it seemed evident that #Ukraine aimed to recapture the island as a PR coup. The island is also strategic as an AA
asset, has legal territorial ramifications, and is potentially important long term for commercial traffic control of the black sea including #Ukraine's vital exports of grains & wheat. The #Russian MoD later claimed there was such an assault & that significant air & other assets
Read 22 tweets
May 8
Now that #Popasna has fallen & the #Siverskyi Donets has been crossed, #Russia is poised to finish the first dramatic encirclement of the war. Any UA troops not falling back to at least the Bakhmut-Siversk line & better the Slovyansk-Kramatorsk-Toretsk line will be surrounded.
They cannot withdraw too fast, & without holding the line because then the front will collapse into a rout, as the RU forces press from the east. Remains to be seen if we see a collapse or an orderly withdrawal but question first is which route #Russia will take?
In general it will continue to take the path of least resistance. It will bypass major roads, fortifications & cities when possible. However it will also be bound by roads and the rail lines in its strategy not only for its own supply but also to cut it off from the #Ukrainians.
Read 18 tweets
May 8
The #Biden administration, #EU and much of the elite in the West think that that they are using #Ukrainian blood to weaken #Russia.

Just some central bank stimulus, money out of thin air, providing support & weapons to #Ukraine whose soldiers will do the actual fighting.
Some may even see parallels, in how American industry supported the Soviet destruction of the Wehrmacht. The Russians provided the endless blood to win WWII. If not they at least cynically use the #Ukraine media craze, built on illogical conclusions derived from false premises
to leverage their uninformed citizens' good will (or shallow need to virtue signal) to meet their strategic geopolitical ends. If a whole lot of Ukrainian and Russian soldiers die in the process, perhaps all the better they say.
Read 23 tweets
May 8
Serhyi wants to live, as he should and as we all. But he whines about rules that he himself has broken. Except he seems to refer to them as if they meant there could never be war (since there are documents with seals on them), and yet he is a Marine. Who would need him then?
He begs for the soldiers of other states to save him. He can live (if he is not a hostage of #Azov as well that is). He can come out with his arms up. That is more than much of the world offers its enemies, & more than his compatriots in many instances offered their Russian foes.
But yes, without human shields, that he should have never had, he can either fight, or surrender. The choice all soldiers in war have, especially when their enemy surrounds them. As a Marine he should know that and stop speaking about reality TV shows...
Read 5 tweets
May 8
#Azovstal's defenders are now increasingly desperate. Especially the deputy battalion commander who now goes by 36th Marine Brigade commander Serhyi Volyna who just hours ago released the following. This because #Ukraine has announced that there are no more women, children or
elderly at #Azovstal. Note that they still refrain from saying "civilians". So #Azov & friends still hide behind civilians, but they just are no longer women, children or elderly. Still, that protection is far reduced & so they fear the potentially incoming #Russian onslaught.
From #Russia's perspective, one could think it may simply act as if there are no longer any civilians at #Azovstal since they are presumably just fighting age men (not children, not elderly) of the enemy. If they won't release them, then they better arm them too. The issue is
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(