, 61 tweets, 17 min read Read on Twitter
Some tweets from tonight's #ACEflagship seminar, in which Ian Hodder (Stanford) shows us his research on Evolution and Entanglement.
Entanglements have diachronic as well as synchronic elements: some processes in entanglements have to happen in specific sequences (clay - brick - house - eroded colluvian - mortar - house, eg)
Since if this work (eg Hägerstrand) uses this site of model to talk about individuals - what about larger groupings eg of styles? #aceflagship
Brick composition at Catalhöyük shows change in time, so do pottery styles (ie functions) #aceflagship
Is there a way of relating these stylistic changes to pathways through time? Can they be explained /understood diachronically?
Some of this stuff reminds me a lot of cladistic theories in linguistics. #ACEflagship
Styles of pottery can be related to learning through time (again, linguistic model is highly relevant) #ACEflagship
However : social learning doesn't = precise imitation. (indeed). Then what does cause persistence? (In linguistics actually persistence is just a null hypothesis - we don't tend to explain it) #ACEflagship
For social theorists, habitus is the key concept - embedded, entanglements, dependencies #ACEflagship
Interesting to think about this from a text angle - textual composition will depend on materials used (oral composition vs clay tablet) #ACEflagship
Hodder opposing that MLWest idea that "composition happens in the mind" - rather, material engagements have to play a role in why practices happen #ACEflagship
Continuity of house construction < continuity of house material and continuity of desire to build a stable structure. #ACEflagship
Is history the passage of objects through time? Seemingly.... Bricks moving from clay to sand => unstable buildings at Catalhöyük
#ACEflagship
Sandier bricks allows larger buildings to be made though : solutions are found to practical issues. But not a matter of "learning", a matter of changed relations with physical objects #ACEflagship
Entanglements are also a matter of symbolic changes though #ACEflagship
Pottery: changes happen as entanglements deepen. Then again : why do entanglements deepen? Eg why do pots suddenly beginning vessels to cook in, process fat/milk etc in? #ACEflagship
Social and cultural, symbolic changes are part of this deepening of the entanglements (or maybe just the increase of entanglements) of pottery #ACEflagship
Pottery's rise is part of the use of sheep products : feedback loop in which pottery becomes more and more involved as the things you do with pottery become more complex, making pottery more and more essential #ACEflagship
Digging in /around the site to manage products of the site => change =>further entanglements. #ACEflagship
Entanglements are generative (linguists are triggered!!) #ACEflagship
You can track individual things (clay balls, pottery, Phragmites etc) but these things are also linked, correlated - they share pathways at different points and diverge at others #ACEflagship
Clay balls : efficient but absorbing cooking. Pots : less efficient, but the pot doesn't require so much attention. So the cook can do other things. #ACEflagship
(apparently that means houses can get bigger, but I'm not sure I get that)
Lukas & Mol: work on Catalhöyük as a whole to see how changes affect each other through time. #ACEflagship
The evolution of spinning. Whorls to wheels to machines to industrial factory production. #ACEflagship
This has to be done via the entanglements of cotton (long slow start followed by 19th c boom) - rather a grim story in effect.... #ACEflagship
Water frame solves the problem created by the British Empire when Indian spinning and English spinning was brought together. English spinning could only compete by inventing technology #ACEflagship
(hm bit sceptical about the mechanics of this tbh)
Industrial revolution caused by the problems of imperialism #ACEflagship
All these things are assemblages / bundles (linking back to our #ACEflagship seminar with @nmacsweeney on fragments)
Basically this is actually refuting the notion of a family tree to think in terms of a "contaminated tradition", as we'd call it in MS studies #ACEflagship
"Tree of life" vs "tree of culture" - but Hodder argues that bundles create conflicts and then change. (dialectic - conflict creates a synthesis, which is the new reality) #ACEflagship
Diagrams used by Hodder based on electromagnetic field diagrams by eg Whitehead #ACEflagship
Entities are processes, not describable in terms of morphology but in terms of diachronic forces that act on them. #ACEflagship
Grist to the mill of those who wrote diachronic grammars (like me!) #ACEflagship
Larry Barham now gives the first response on behalf of @LivAncWorlds
LB: begins with some comments on how learning works #ACEflagship
LB: can mathematical modelling cope in every case?
LB: handaxe - most persistent artefact. But why should that be?
Are handaxes instinctive? #ACEflagship
Now Violaine Chauvet responds on behalf of Egyptology for @LivAncWorlds
VC: sceptical about quantitative methods for simplifying human life as reflected in material culture #ACEflagship
VC: queries on methodology. How do we define conjunction and correlation? Synchrony / diachrony - when entangled and when coincidental? Can change be autonomous? (really good point) #ACEflagship
VC: needs vs wants - needs (responses to change) while wants effect change for self interest
VC: Egyptology - what roles does/can text play on entanglement? (again really interesting problem) #ACEflagship
VC: Text and Material culture don't always change together - how do we deal with this? #ACEflagship
VC: restricted knowledge : how control of knowledge implicated in change (restricting / enabling)?
VC: patriarchy: @LivAncWorlds subjects are often heavily male and elite - sectors of society have been silenced or underrepresented. Who were things made for? Cs an entanglement theory help with social changes and conflicts in the absence of evidence #ACEflagship
Barnstorming performance by Violaine! @LivAncWorlds #ACEflagship
Correlation vs causation : objects linked because you can invent a story to account for it. Simultaneity then is causation iff you can find a way of explaining both things together #ACEflagship
Needs vs wants : the distinction between cultural and biological wants /needs are too fused to distinguish. #ACEflagship
Cultural changes have influence on the genome (epigenetic and new biology) - so culture and biology can't be distinguished #ACEflagship
Material and text : ideas are connected to the world BUT some pathways are more persistent and therefore allow for entanglements #ACEflagship
Entanglements are multi temporal : things are of different ages at the same time #ACEflagship
Women and silenced voices. More entanglement = more control = more inequality. Gender differentiation supposed to emerge towards the end of the Catalhöyük society (though Hodder dubious this is true). #ACEflagship
Is this about stories that are told rather than what is "actually" happening? #ACEflagship
Questions from the floor are now open #ACEflagship
A question has just been asked "what about missing evidence?"
Answer : "pick sites with lots of evidence" hmmmm
In any case, if entanglements are specific and local and embedded, they aren't models you can just lift up and apply #ACEflagship
Ian Hodder with @LivAncWorlds students
Oh and @preshitorian!!
@threadreaderapp please unroll for @emily_prtak
@LivAncWorlds this is a thread about our - your - Flagship seminar last night. Please retweet it!
Missing some Tweet in this thread?
You can try to force a refresh.

Like this thread? Get email updates or save it to PDF!

Subscribe to Ben Cartlidge
Profile picture

Get real-time email alerts when new unrolls are available from this author!

This content may be removed anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Follow Us on Twitter!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just three indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3.00/month or $30.00/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!