,
12 tweets,
3 min read
Read on Twitter
We keep hearing that Trump is some sort of uniquely dishonest politician and journalists need to be vigilant and constantly call him a liar. The we get stuff like this reported uncritically. usatoday.com/story/news/nat… 
How much will it cost to "pay for the health care insurance costs for 600,000 city residents"? "About $100 million a year." That amounts to $167 a year per person.
That's 1.7% of the $9,845 cost per enrollee of New York state's Medicaid program in 2016, as per Ballotpedia. ballotpedia.org/Medicaid_spend…
The fake news story itself contains numbers that ought to call de Blasio's into question.
New York state's population is 130% greater than New York state's population. According to these figures, the cost of providing "comprehensive health care" statewide would be 170,000% as much as de Blasio claims he'll spend doing so in the city.
The statewide figure doesn't quite add up either if the comparison is apples to apples. Divide $170 billion by the state population and you get $8,564 per person, which is within the magnitude of current Medicaid spending.
So maybe it's a (lowball) estimate of total annual spending under a statewide single-payer regime. Still, there's no way de Blasio's promise of insuring 600,000 people for $100 million a year adds up.
It appears the reporter here is just parroting numbers without understanding what they mean, or even questioning them.
We do get this vaguely skeptical quote in grafs 12-13.
But here's the headline. How is this better than "Mexico to Pay for Wall, President Announces"?
End of rant.
*than New York City's population
