I finished @mashagessen stunning book👇
I am left with two distinct thoughts:
First: I see why Putin methods work on America’s far right wing.
Second: I see why Putin’s methods are unlikely to succeed in the U.S.
(Examples of Putin's methods are "Firehose of Falsehoods" & "Crisis and spectacle":
rand.org/pubs/perspecti… )
She quotes Bálint Magyar, who says: “the conditions preceding the democratic big bang have a decisive role in the formation of the system.”
Soviet totalitarianism created a "barren intellectual landscape" and an "ideological vacuum."
Free thinking wasn’t permitted. To be a “critical thinker” in a Soviet university meant spotting where a person deviated from the Party line.
His aim was to understand what kind of regime the Soviet Union had been, and what Russia was becoming.
After the Soviet Union fell, “The country was in a state of high anxiety.”
For a while, though, it looked hopeful that Homo Sovieticus could embrace democracy and freedom (and diversity, which always grows in a true democracy).
At the time of the Russian Big Bang, only 1/3 believed homosexuals should be liquidated. 10% believed they should be left alone.
Things, though, didn’t go well. Attempts to privatize the nation’s industries and distribute wealth created opportunities for corruption.
Democracy never took hold.
The Russian people remained poor with the impression that “crooks, con men” and “criminals” were getting rich.
As Putin consolidated his power, his regime whipped up the old hysteria over homosexuals, and the number of people who wanted to "liquidate" homosexuals grew again.
The conditions at the time of the American Big Bang were different.
There was no intellectual vacuum. The drafters of the Constitution were well-versed in the classics & philosophy, which they used for guidance.
Private property was widely distributed: Wealth and power were entirely in the hands of elite white men—but there were a lot of them and they were spread out.
The white men of the American colonies rejected a king, and—living dispersed in colonies—were used to doing as they pleased and governing themselves.
A kind of representative democracy thus took hold in the U.S.— a democracy in which a certain portion of the population (white men) enjoyed freedom & opportunity.
They established democratic institutions. . . .
Note: Gessen talks only about Russia. Facts about the U.S. Big Bang come from my own research.