@Special relationship" is a #delusion that Indians must #shun if they are to defend their Nation against Autocratic nations which have been looking for a way to destroy them for 75 years
Make no mistake, Putin's Damocles sword is now hanging over India's head. We don't have the luxury of talking🤐, we have to plan, decide, and act!
There are only "overlapping interests," between any two countries; When the overlap gets smaller & smaller, expect foreign policies to change; don't #delude yourself about friendship, Bhai Bhai & Jigri Dosti
4/Irus It's now crystal clear, that FM Lavrov's criticism of India in 2021 was not an emotional outburst. It represents Putin's/Kremlin's view about India & its role in Quad/Indo-Pacific! P* swallowed his pride in Dec 2021, to ensure India wouldn't vote against Russia in UN
8/irus Indian lives matter to India, whether they are Indian students in Middle East or Europe, the target of cross-border terrorism, or aggression by China (as much as European lives matter to Europeans).
9/irus Following the US-UK-EU conventional wisdom (#CW) & “expert consensus” is likely to lead India into disaster. We have to think & decide for ourselves, after listening to all voices, particularly of dissidents like👇🏽!
10/irus And, “EU will opt to align with the United States to balance Russia, but not to isolate China” . Guess which is (un)acceptable in the eyes of US-EU Foreign policy experts?
11/irus That said, we do need to consider th difference between #Grey#War that #India has faced from #Pakistan & #China for 50yrs, and traditional, full fledged, hot #War that #USA launched against #Iraq, & #Russia against #Ukraine. Latter is shocking precursor to #PRC war on 🇹🇼
12/irus I have searched for a decade for an analysis of how GOI’s public denunciation of, “China as an Aggressor” will benefit India (net-net); its even more difficult to understand how denunciation of “Russia as an aggressor” will help, & not harm, Indian interests! 🙏🏽 enlighten
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Better late than never. We all make mistakes. The critical test will be how German policy on #China changes (not Russia policy, which is fairly predictable)
3/eu The lesson is applicable to India-China! Remember Military strength requires both funds and Partnerships (to get technology & advanced equipment at lowest cost)
True, but there is a fine line between friendly advice and #Information#Warfare. My friends advise me privately and politely, not criticise me on social media, or give me advice on TV interviews! Those who did the latter are no longer my friends 🤡.
3/pip #PIP: “The concept of “Friendship” in IR has been the bane of Indian foreign policy; Indians get emotionally committed to it, while great powers use it as an instrument of moral/intellectual coercion!” Asymmetric tests of “logical consistency” are another tool of coercion
Which is the greater military power: #PRC with 60,000 troops massed on India’s border(for ~2 years) or #RF with 100,000 troops massed on Ukraine border(for ~ 2 months)?
2/rus #Russian massing of troops around Ukraine is not just a message to #USA and #Europe, but also to #China and #India, not to write off its Military power & ability to use it; even though Russia’s economic power is now much less than that of USA, EU, China, India.🧐🤔
3/rus The #Russian’s have learned from the #PRC aggression against India in 2020, which rapidly lost credibility after Galwan. They have done everything to ensure that the threat of invasion is credible enough to achieve their coercive objectives without fighting.
Progress on restoring April 2020 status quo ante in Ladakh, was interrupted by IA thwarting 2 aggressive PLA patrols across LOC & Xi's fear of ultra-nationalist reaction (before elevation to top pantheon of CCP), resumes. 60% probability of PLA, Hot-spring withdrawal, by Dec 31
3/pla Traditionally #PLA#Creeping#Acquisition has been attempted between the dotted lines(👇🏼). Since August 2020 all such attempts have been #successfully#resisted. All reported construction is in areas under PLA control for decades(ie btwn top line & next dotted line)