Profile picture
Helena Cobban @helenacobban
, 22 tweets, 5 min read Read on Twitter
[Thread] 1. I've been trying to figure out the source of MBS's extreme hatred/fear of #JamalKhashoggi. For starters, it's key to note that though JK had a long track record in journalism, he was also a political actor. >
2. He's had close ties to Prince Turki al-Faisal (fmr longtime head of Saudi intelligence, more recently ambo in London & DC) & to other non-MBS royals. It's also no secret he recently had good relations with the Muslim Brotherhood, >
3. a historic, transnational organiz'n containing a number of trends. E.g. the MB branches in Egypt & Palestine participated in elections & committed to an electoral process (& both suffered much for that), while that in Syria has been much more committed to violence. >
4. In the past 18 months or so, in addition to picking up the interesting gig as a contributor to @WaPo's Global Opinions, he has reportedly been planning for creation of a pro-democracy movement focused on Saudi Arabia. >
5. So it seems this, based on the broad reach of JK's connections both inside & outside the eponymous "Saudi" royal family, aroused MBS's v. intense ire. Easy to see how MBS wd be spooked to learn of opposition to his already-grisly & maniacal dictatorship from his cousins, >
6. But the combination of intra-family oppositn with extra-family opposition from e.g. pro-MB networks was likely seen by MBS & his enforcers as so incendiary as to justify "extreme measures" such as reportedly were taken. I knew JK just a little.>
7. Back in '05, I was running an international workshop on nonviolence at/with the UN University's (now-defunct) campus in Amman, Jordan. It was a weird experience. But w/ encouragement from the people running that UNU program I went to see then-ambo Turki in his DC office >
8. to see if we could get his approval for some Saudi citizens to attend. (Yes, it was a weird experience, as many UN operations are.) Turki called in his "advisor", JK, to attend that meeting & to my surprise said JK himself wd take part in the 2-day workshop. Not exactly >
9. the kind of "young citizen activist" we'd had in mind, but I'd done enough "Track 2" diplomatic things by then that I thought getting a foot in the KSA door seemed a good thing. JK did come to the workshop & took part in all the exercises etc with good humor. >
10. So of course it's been v. shocking to learn via the Turkish-govt leaks about the unspeakable things MBS's goons reportedly did to Jamal in the consulate. RIP; and my deep condolences to his fiancee & the rest of his family. But again-- WHY this extreme brutality, which now >
11. looks very counter-productive indeed & also (since we have to assume that MBS is not entirely stupid) must have been viewed as very risky indeed when he & his goons were planning it. So why? I think the threat they saw Jamal as posing was not only from the "Al-Saud" cousins >
12. But also from his ties to MB-linked circles given that in many contexts the MB has proven to be effective in building grassroots civilian movements that offer a *modern* form of Islam to Muslims, thus competing directly with his claims to be a "modernizer". Also, the MB >
13. has kept to the very traditional Muslim opposition to any form of (inheritable) monarchy; does not believe in either kings or princes, and promotes traditional Islamic virtues of egalitarianism. I don't know what support the MB has among Saudi citizens. >
14. Maybe it's like the Falun Gong in China: An autocratic government will always fear self-organizing citizen movements. But I do know that very many Saudi citizens are outraged by the profligacy of the royals, the double standards they enjoy; and many Saudis are also >
15. deeply offended by the ease with which so many royals flout the basic tenets of their faith and flaunt their wealth domestically & in international settings. So the constituency for an MB-type movement is almost certainly there, both among Saudi citizens & >
16. among many of their non-Saudi hired hands. If someone cd create an alliance between non-MBS royals v angry at his usurpation of their powers, privileges, boondoggles, & bottom lines and a potential popular movement inside "Saudi" Arabia (aka the Arabian Peninsula), >
17. then that wd be explosively threatening to MBS & justify him & his goons taking great risks. I should note tho tht ever since King Faisal was killed by a nephew (w CIA ties??) in 1975, no Saudi king has *ever* taken on the challenge of governing with any seriousness & hence >
18. for > 40 years, *very* few Saudi princes have received any serious training in the arts of governance or anything else socially useful except libertinism and idleness. So the "bench" of princes capable of envisaging a persuasive alternative to MBS or planning >
19. its implementation is thin, indeed. What does all this mean? Well, clearly, there is a crisis in Saudi-US relations (based as they are primarily on the Saudis giving massive dollops of $$ to US businesses/consultancies/etc.) & this is almost certainly spooking Saudi royals >
20. & the few other members of the country's elite who are worth counting as players, very deeply indeed. MBS has worked hard & fast over the almost 4 years since his Dad became "King", to cut off access to levers of power from being held by anyone else except himself >
21. & that almost certainly also includes his deeply geriatric Dad. But might Dad be able to disavow this son and switch the designation of "Crown Prince" elsewhere? In a crisis like this, he loyalties of the heads of the ctry's various security orgs are crucial. >
22. In this sense, the atmosphere inside Riyadh today is almost certainly Shakespearean: Julius Caesar; Macbeth; Richard II... I wish I had time to write more about this. But stay tuned for lots more news coming out of Riyadh in the coming days & weeks.
Missing some Tweet in this thread?
You can try to force a refresh.

Like this thread? Get email updates or save it to PDF!

Subscribe to Helena Cobban
Profile picture

Get real-time email alerts when new unrolls are available from this author!

This content may be removed anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just three indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member and get exclusive features!

Premium member ($30.00/year)

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!