A thread:
But running backs don’t “not matter”. They matter on a spectrum between quarterbacks and long-snappers.
Granted, they're probably closer to the latter than the former.
In fact, (no hyperbole), there’s not too much separating the value created by elite pass-catching running backs and elite pass-catching tight ends.
It’s an easier comparison anyway due to chip blocks obscuring our route run data (for both RBs and TEs but not WRs).
1. Travis Kelce (TE)
2. George Kittle (TE)
3. Alvin Kamara (RB)
4. Mark Andrews (TE)
5. Todd Gurley (RB)
6. Christian McCaffrey (RB)
7. Eric Ebron (TE)
8. Kareem Hunt (RB)
Total
Tight Ends: 4
Running Backs: 4
- All Running Backs: 1.31 yards per route run
- All Tight Ends: 1.29 yards per route run
- Running Backs: 1.61 yards per route run
- Tight Ends: 1.61 yards per route run
- Running Backs: 1.69 yards per route run
- Tight Ends: 1.69 yards per route run
Who owns some truly absurd numbers, that hold up against some of the league’s best tight ends:
On the whole, this is very true.
Of those seasons, the r^2 to YPRR in the following season is:
- Running Backs: 0.017
- Tight Ends: 0.242
(This is bad.)
If we remove the Isaiah Crowell’s of the world, do our numbers become stronger?
When looking only at these RBs, we have 102 instances of a RBs totaling at least 25 targets in back to back seasons. For the top-17 TEs we have 140 seasons.
- Top-17 running backs: 0.192
- Top-17 tight ends: 0.190
This BLEW MY MIND.
I don’t think Zeke is deserving of a massive contract (comparable to high-end TEs) but maybe Alvin Kamara and Christian McCaffrey are.
/fin
This blurb links here (2017): pff.com/news/fantasy-f…
and here (2018): pff.com/news/fantasy-f…
/fin