Thread by @ThePlumLineGS

1) The new testimony from David Holmes breaks important new ground -- and it has broader implications than it first appears.

It leads inevitably to a conclusion that completely blows apart one of the biggest defenses of Trump coming from his propagandists right now.

*THREAD*

2) Holmes, an embassy staffer in Kiev, testified that he, too, overheard Trump demanding via loud cell-phone voice to know from Gordon Sondland whether Zelensky would pursue the sham “investigation” (i.e., smear) of Biden that he wanted.

3) According to Holmes, Sondland says Trump cares more about whether Ukraine is investigating Biden -- the “big stuff” -- than he does about Ukraine itself.

This undercuts the nonsense that Trump only cared about getting Ukraine to investigate generic “corruption.”

4) Here Trump’s ringleader is also revealing that Trump is incapable of thinking about anything except through the prism of what helps him politically.

This goes to corrupt intent -- to the subversion and manipulation of foreign policy to serve Trump’s own corrupt ends.

5) But Holmes’ testimony reveals two other things as well.

First, Trump has a direct and open line to Sondland, to get briefed on every step of the unfolding plot -- and to provide direction to Sondland throughout.

Second, Trump is obsessing over how the plot is playing out.

6) Given all this, it is extremely hard to see how Sondland could have freelanced the extortion piece of the plot, without direction from Trump -- an argument that Trump’s propagandists are now making constantly.

7) As the plot hit its climax, Sondland had three important conversations -- two with William Taylor, and one with Tim Morrison.

In those conversations, Sondland detailed his discussions with Trump himself.

I’ve detailed these talks below:

washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/…

8) Given that Trump was obsessing over the plot and directing Sondland, it takes a huge leap to invent a scenario in which Sondland *wasn’t* taking direction from Trump when he conveyed the extortion message to Ukraine.

Here’s what you’d have to believe:

washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/…

9) Those things don’t seem very likely.

Do they?

FIN