Profile picture
Chris Geidner @chrisgeidner
, 55 tweets, 9 min read Read on Twitter
The Kavanaugh confirmation hearing has begun, and Democrats ask for the hearing to be postponed for a multitude of reasons — including the new 42,000 pages of docs turned over last night (Harris) and the 100,000 docs withheld w a claim but not assertion of privilege (Whitehouse).
Leahy: "What are we trying to hide? What are we rushing?"
Protesters, also, are regularly interrupting the hearing. Loudly, and with signs.
Grassley, on the fact that Ginsburg's ACLU documents weren't turned over, which Grassley says was a part of attorney-client privilege: "It can't be that the ACLU receives more protections than the President of the United States."
Grassley continues with the line that the committee has more Kavanaugh docs than from prior nominees and concludes: "I suspect that Judge Kavanaugh will become the next Associate Justice of the Supreme Court."
Here we go again, with Dems asking for a vote on a motion to adjourn the hearing — based in part on the executive privilege issue.
Cornyn says that all of the Dems would be held in contempt if this was a court of law.

Leahy: "Oh, come on."
Here is the letter asking the White House to withdraw the privilege claim (which was not formally invoked and was decided on by DOJ) being used to keep 100,000+ pages of Kavanaugh's record secret. documentcloud.org/documents/4823…
Sen. Klobuchar referenced the letter in her remarks.
We're still going back and forth with questions. Sen. Kennedy was asking about committee process, which was a nice throw-back to a simpler time.
Blumenthal: The chairman has no right to overrule that rule (requiring a vote) by fiat.

Grassley says that rule only applies in executive session and they're not in exec session now.
Grassley says the "committee confidential" documents are so "under federal law."
I did @AM2DM, came back, and Blumenthal is still asking for the committee to consider his motion to adjourn.
Hatch talks about how many documents they have. This is such a false argument, given that all knew, going in, that Kavanaugh would have more docs than past nominees. Nonetheless, he was nominated. Then, Republicans turned foot and just decided not to seek most of his records.
Leahy: "All told, only 4% of [Kavanaugh']s White House record has been shared with the public; only 7% with the committee." In contrast, "99% of Justice Kagan's records were available to all of the public. What is being hidden and why? ... It's not only shameful, it's a sham."
Leahy, saying he's seen more confirmation hearings than anyone else in the Senate, calls this the "most incomplete, most partisan, least transparent" confirmation hearing he has seen.
Grassley says it's "ridiculous" to say that the committee doesn't have enough documents because they have more documents than for the 5 last nominees combined.

Booker: "It's not the number of documents."
Sen. Cornyn doesn't like how this morning is going: "I hope we can take a breath," which he says the committee has not been successful at doing this morning, "and get a grip."
Sen. Durbin: "What we've heard is the noise of democracy. It is not 'mob rule.'" Durbin goes on to describe the big issue behind questions about Kavanaugh as being about him being "[Trump's] man."
Six of the top 10 trending topics in the US on Twitter as we approach noon today are about Brett Kavanaugh's Supreme Court nomination hearing.
Sen. Lee took us through a history of Supreme Court confirmation hearings, so that happened.
The White House responds to Durbin's claim that Kavanaugh misled the Senate Judiciary Committee during his DC Circuit confirmation hearing, saying that it is Durbin who is being "deliberately misleading."
Meanwhile, Sen. Whitehouse is focusing in his opening statement on "the Roberts Five," a focus on 5-4 votes that have gone the conservative way, particularly on corporate interests.
An important note about the news that former Sen. Jon Kyl is expected to be named to serve as the interim senator to fill Sen. John McCain's seat.
Cruz says Kavanaugh's records from his time as staff secretary aren't important as to Kavanaugh's thinking. "The staff secretary is simply the funnel," Cruz says.
Cruz says this would be about opening up records to relitigate the George W. Bush administration's decision. ... Wait, now Cruz is saying Dems' efforts are an attempt to relitigate the 2016 election.
Cruz says that a Supreme Court vacancy was "directly on the ballot" in 2016. (He had a different ballot than I had.)
Ted Cruz just invoked the Shakespearian "full of sound and fury, signifying nothing." It was not, however, about himself.
Side-note: As we break for lunch, Deputy AG Rod Rosenstein, who his been in attendance, said a few words to White House counsel Don McGahn, also in attendance.
The White House isn't happy that Dems are asking about documents. Just got this from them:
Arizona Gov. Ducey specifically notes Jon Kyl's role in helping advance Kavanaugh's nomination in the Senate, then adds, "Now, Sen. Kyl can vote for [Judge Kavanaugh]'s confirmation."
The hearing is back on.
Grassley says that Dems are being deceptive with their figure about the % of Kavanaugh documents available to the committee because Dems' number of total docs is based on NARA's estimate of the # of docs and b/c Dems are including "irrelevant staff secretary documents."
Klobuchar focuses on Kavanaugh’s writings and opinions on executive power in her opening statement.
I can’t believe I ran out to grab lunch and am missing this.
Blumenthal is focused on Trump's attacks on the rule of law and law enforcement — and the role of the judiciary in standing up to such attacks.
Blumenthal says the 42K pages of documents were not uploaded to the software being used by both parties until 6:45a this morning, so he doesn't know how the majority staff reviewed them last night.
Blumenthal: "By law, these documents belong to the American people. They don't belong to President Bush or President Trump. It's only a matter of time."
After continual denial from Grassley to consider Blumenthal's motion to adjourn and Blumenthal's appeal of the decision of the chair, Blumenthal says, "I will proceed, under protest."
Cornyn questions whether people are taking too much time.

Grassley basically says, yes, but that he hadn't stopped it before, so he won't now: "Either you run the committee or the committee runs you, and I let the committee run me this time."
Blumenthal: "If you are confirmed after this truncated and concealed process, there will always be a taint. There will always be an asterisk after your name."
Sen. Kennedy: "I'm not looking for an ideologue. I'm not looking for a hater." He also wants a judge who knows how to use a semicolon.
Here are the Blumenthal "asterisk" comments:
Booker opened his opening with a bit more fight on documents, but then pivoted to this —>
Tillis says he's really impressed that Kavanaugh and his family have handled ... sitting in the hearing room today.
Sen. Lindsey Graham is up, and he's in a mood: "This is shaping up to be the hypocrisy hearings, and that's tough to do in the Senate today. ... This is ridiculous."
Lisa Blatt, Rob Portman, and Condoleezza Rice have entered the committee hearing room to do the introductions of Brett Kavanaugh.
After rather snooze-y introductions from Rice and Portman, Lisa Blatt is up.
Blatt introduces herself as a liberal Democrat, whose hero is Ginsburg, who voted for Clinton and Obama, and who says she wishes Feinstein and not Grassley was chairing the hearing. Nonetheless, she says she's here to support Kavanaugh's nomination.
Blatt, who regularly appears before the Supreme Court: "I received many angry calls from friends and strangers for supporting Judge Kavanaugh ... At the end of the day, I enthusiastically support Judge Kavanaugh."
Kavanaugh, at long last, speaks. He says Justice Kennedy's legacy is best summed up in one word: "Liberty."
Kavanaugh, speaking about his work on the DC Circuit, praises "our superb chief judge, Merrick Garland."
JUST IN: US Capitol Police report 70 arrests today associated with the Kavanaugh hearings, including 61 people removed from the committee room.
And, for a wrap on what happened today at the Kavanaugh confirmation hearing (day one), check out my and @ZoeTillman's story at the @BuzzFeedNews site: buzzfeednews.com/article/zoetil…
Missing some Tweet in this thread?
You can try to force a refresh.

Like this thread? Get email updates or save it to PDF!

Subscribe to Chris Geidner
Profile picture

Get real-time email alerts when new unrolls are available from this author!

This content may be removed anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just three indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member and get exclusive features!

Premium member ($3.00/month or $30.00/year)

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!