#Thread to counter this (pseudo) logic making rounds in the trads circle to justify their imaginary restriction of women to study and chant Vedas. #vedas #SanatanDharma #women #dharma #chanting
This one is concerned to the anatomy of females which according to them are not suitable for chanting of Vedic hymns. Trads/tradcells (inspired by their Gurus) claim chanting of Vedic mantra affects the reproductive organs of women,..
.. by burning their uterus over period of time, while in case of men their organ remains intact !
For argument sake, even if we accept it, let trads and their gurus provide atleast one scientific and historical instance or evidence of a woman who has lost her reproductive system due to Vedas.
.. From the Ancient Rishikas like Lopamudra, Gargee, Romasha, Ghosha, including Brahmavadinis and Vedic scholars like Maitreyi, Ubhaya Bharti and others who find mention in Ved Vyas’s Mahabharata and even Puranas etc..
and as late as as female ascetics encountered by Kalidasa 1500 years ago, there is no single evidence of any scholarly women suffering from any anatomical abnormalities due to Vedic studies and chanting of Vedas.
There is mention of nearly 60 Rishikas (female Rishis) and Brahmavadinis who expounded Vedic suktas and achieved expertise in Vedic wisdom in our Sanatan History.
Unfortunately most of the divisions/mandalas of Vedas are lost in due course of time. Who knows how many more such female Rishikas r also lost in time ?? An approximate list of female Vedic scholars from Ancient India is attached here, courtesy : desiprism from Instagram
My question to all those Gurus and their followers : if you are true Sanatanis, do u really believe that Vedas, Which are the divine words of the Ishwar, will ever harm any of His creations ?
Agreed Vedic chanting MUST be done properly after being thoroughly trained by a recognised guru since the same produces vibrations and needs high level of dedication.
However, in worst case scenario, wrong chanting would result to your undesirable results. It can never cause harm you, be in Male or female, because as mentioned in Yajurveda 26.2, Ishwar has given Vedas for all irrespective of class and gender.
.. Also, if at all Vedas wld have been dangerous for women, Panini, the legendary grammarian from Ancient India, won’t have been fool enough to coin terminologies like Acharyaa (lady teacher) & upadhyayaa (lady preceptor) Who used to teach Vedas to girl students in Kanya Gurukul
Such misconceptualised reasons are nothing but Pseudoscience which is part of a nefarious propaganda to keep our eligible Hindu women away from the supreme divine knowledge and wisdom in Sanatan Dharma,..
.. Which itself has originated from Maa Gayatri who is regarded as Mother of Vedas, a woman herself. Is this not utter hypocrisy? Some trads started this propaganda in Middle Ages and their bloodline are continuing this even now.
In the modern era, there are thousands and thousands of girls and women who are studying and teaching Vedas in countless Kanya Gurukuls across the country run by Arya Samaj, Patanjali, Art of Living, Isha Foundation etc...
Has there been any case of anatomical deformity due to Vedas in any woman from such Gurukuls or Have later become sterile ???
Personally speaking, my mother, my mother in law chant Gayatri Mantra daily, for kind information of all trads, I, my sister, wife , brother in law etc, all grew up fine and are all safe and sound.
So let’s come out of this gender prejudice propagated in name of this illogical pseudo science which is clearly not part of our glorious eternal Sanatan Dharma. Let our daughters, sisters, wives, mothers etc , if interested & eligible, study Vedas and practice Vedic way of life.
History is the witness and as glorified multiple times in Atharveda, Yajurv Vedas and even Manusmiriti, if women, the spark of Adi Para Shakti, are kept spiritually illiterate, society and Dharma will decline eventually,...
.. and unfortunately, we have already set ourselves in the course of destruction unless we bring about some drastic change in the way we learn and implement our Dharmic teachings and wisdoms, irrespective of Varna and gender.
We complain a lot about rapid surge in cases of ‘love jihad’ where willingly or unwillingly Hindu girls elope with M guys and most of them convert, discarding their original Vedic Sanatan Dharma. One of the reasons for this is keeping women away from supreme Vedic knowledge.
Let us note, unlike trads who believe in forcible seclusion of Hindu females as a measure to counter Love Jihad, Manusmiriti 9.12 says clearly that women can’t be secured or protected through force. It is only through her intellect and wisdom she can defend herself.
Finally before ending this thread,please let Check out and share the following videos of modern day Vedacharyaa teaching Vedas and it’s chanting to young girls in Kanya Gurukulas. 👇
Let me reassure all that the Vedacharyaa here as well as her girl students are quite healthy and their anatomy including female reproductive organs are all safe and sound. The only change in them is positive and enlightening spiritually and psychologically.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Subhrajyoti

Subhrajyoti Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @subhra2jyoti

3 Nov
#Thread on ‘nakedness in native clothing’ in certain regions of South India as recorded by European travellers,merchants & Persian ambassador in 1200-1500 CE before advent of Islamic/Christian/Victorian morality in societies :- #History #India #Bharat #Naked #Culture #SouthIndia ImageImage
A)John of Monte Corvino, one of the first Christian Monks who spent considerable time in South India preaching, observed dressing style of men and women in certain regions of Indian peninsula during 12-13th century CE:- Image
“They (Men and women) are not, strictly speaking, black, but of an olive colour, and exceedingly well formed both women and men. They go barefoot and naked, except that they wear a cloth round the loins, and boys and girls up to eight years of age wear nothing whatever,.. ImageImage
Read 25 tweets
29 Oct
#Thread on how Arab traveller, Al-Jahiz of Basra (present day Iraq) [?-864 CE] wrote ‘highly’ of Indians labelling them being ‘meritorious’ based on his journey in India in mid-9th CE.👇#History #India #Bharat #Medieval #Medicine #Astronomy #Arab
“The inhabitants of India are highly meritorious in astrology and medicine. They have a peculiar script. In medicine too they have a supreme insight...
.. They have in their possession some strange secrets of the art of Aesculapius (Roman God of Medicine). They have medicines for some very fell diseases.
Read 19 tweets
25 Oct
This is what Arab Geographer and traveller, Abu Zaidu-l Hasan, of Siraf (916 CE-?) [who based on his travel to India in 10th century CE and reading and questioning Persian and Arab travellers and merchants to India like Sulaiman and Al Masudi,...
.. compiled and supplemented the travelogues] has recorded about royal women and veils👇 in Medieval India m, before Islamic rule firmly established in India :-
#veil #History #India #Medieval #woman #royal #princess #thread
“Royal women are not veiled.Most of the princes of India, when they hold a court, allow their women to be seen by the men who attend it, whether they be natives or foreigners.

No veil conceals them from the eyes of the visitor.”
Read 14 tweets
21 Oct
#Thread on whether we had Dowry system (the way it is prevalent in present society) in Medieval India ? #History #Marriage #Dowry #Stridhan #Hindu #SanatanDharma #Women #Medieval #Bharat #India
We will be analysing the following travel records of medieval time Arab and Chinese travelers, traders and scholars like Alberuni (970-1039 CE) [who came to India with Mahmud Ghazni and stayed here for a substantial time chiefly in Punjab],..
.. Chau Ju-Kua (a foreign trade inspector) who compiled his work in about 1225 CE and has given a good insight on South India and Ma Twan-lin, who travelled and recorded about South India in mid-13th century CE. All the following information on whether..
Read 33 tweets
10 Oct
Mini- #Thread on islands of #Lakshadweep and #Maldives as observed and recorded by Sulaiman, the Arab merchant (who undertook several voyages to India and China),in his travel diary, known as ‘Akhbar Al-Sin wa’l Hind’ dated 851 CE. #History #India #Islamic #medieval #Bharat
“The third sea is the Sea of Harkandh [from Sanskrit Harikeliya, Bay of Bengal]. Between it and the Sea of Larvi there are numerous islands. It is said that they are one thousand and nine hundred islands, and they mark the boundaries of these two seas,..
.. namely Larvi [Lata for Gujarat] and Harkandh... In these islands, ruled by the woman, coconut palms grow in abundance. The distance between one island and the other is two, three or four farsakh, and each one of these is inhabited by people and has coconut palms...
Read 10 tweets
9 Oct
Rig Veda 1.32.11

दा॒सप॑त्नी॒रहि॑गोपा अतिष्ठ॒न्निरु॑द्धा॒ आपः॑ प॒णिने॑व॒ गावः॑ ।
अ॒पां बिल॒मपि॑हितं॒ यदासी॑द्वृ॒त्रं ज॑घ॒न्वाँ अप॒ तद्व॑वार ॥
#vedas #SanatanDharma #hindu #Hinduism
Word-Meaning: -
हे सभापते ! (पाणिनेव) गाय आदि पशुओं के पालने और (गावः) गौओं को यथायोग्य स्थानों में रोकनेवाले के समान (दासपत्नीः) अति बल देनेवाला मेघ जिनका पति के समान और (अहिगोपाः) रक्षा करनेवाला है वे (निरुद्धाः) रोके हुए (आपः) (अतिष्ठन्) स्थित होते हैं उन (अपाम्) जलों का (यत्)
जो (बिलम्) गर्त्त अर्थात् एक गढ़े के समान स्थान (अपहितम्) ढ़ापसा रक्खा (आसीत्)* उस (वृत्रम्) मेघ को सूर्य (जघन्वान्) मारता है मारकर (तत्) उस जल की (अपववार) रुकावट तोड़ देता है वैसे आप शत्रुओं को दुष्टाचार से रोक के न्याय अर्थात् धर्ममार्ग को प्रकाशित रखिये ॥११॥
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!