Subhrajyoti Profile picture
Sep 15, 2020 23 tweets 13 min read Read on X
Review on Growth of Scheduled Castes and Tribes in Medieval India by Dr K S Lal. [#Thread ] #History #india #scheduledtribe #scheduledcaste #caste #indic #civilization #Hindus #hinduism #SanatanDharma #medieval #bharat
This well researched book is a gem for all those who are curious to learn the actual state of the present day STs/SCs during Medieval Ages, especially in Hindu Society.
It challenges and devastates the false extreme narrative built first by colonial Western Indologists and later popularised by Marxists Historians, that Hindu upper castes used to unleash unimaginable amount of inhuman atrocities on lower castes..
.. and hence are the major reason for the widespread poverty among lower castes.

It focuses on following salient points which the historian has quite lucidly & convincingly proved based by countless primary sources from contemporary times and recent research post independence:-
1. The primary reason for rapid increase in massive number of SCs and STs in medieval india is large scale fleeing of city and village dwellers to deep forests and mountains, on account of oppressive Islamic tax collectors and rulers...
.. Upon staying disconnected from their original culture, these fleeing communities developed new set of own rites, rituals etc which shaped their new culture in forests.
2. Upper & Lower castes has always fought shoulder to shoulder against the Islamic invasions, for the Islamic forces did not distinguish between the difference castes/classes in Hindi society.
.. Hence, there tenet commanded them to look down on all as kaafirs, deserving to be force converted or butchered mercilessly.
3. Statistics say while mostly the upper caste converted under different circumstances, the lower caste had pride in their culture and community and avoided adopting Islam during Medieval Ages.
4. Untouchablity was primarily due to the abhorrence of most of Hindus population towards anybody who takes beef or any similar animal, irrespective of caste, religion etc. (including Westerners and Islamists)
5. Restrictions on entry of lower castes into temples was never a widespread phenomenon. In the book, the author has talked about the basic design of most of the temples in India which does not allow much of public space for masses..
.. and thus restricts most of the population in the city or village in its premises...
However, in all public events like Rath Yatra, or any event where God or Goddess is taken around in a religious procession, there is no historical evidence of any restrictions on basis of caste or creed.
6. Most importantly, it should be noted whatever disabilities we read about imposed on lower castes, it is primarily due to the foreign regimes who caused it through their religious, social and political discriminations and atrocious polices towards Hindus in general.
7. In those times too like now, there were some orthodox narrow minded Who discriminated against lower castes but such population was alway minimal and their action was never in vogue.
Overall, quite informative and thought provoking book by Dr K S Lal. A must for young minds who have set in search of nothing but the truth regarding our Sanatan Civilisation.
My review can be also accessed in Goodreads here - goodreads.com/review/show/31…
Disclaimer: Uploaded the wrong photo instead of K S Lal’s . Please ignore the same and read through the matter. Thanks to @limitlessarya ji 🙏for pointing it out.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Subhrajyoti

Subhrajyoti Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @subhra2jyoti

Jun 26, 2021
#Thread on celebrating indomitable #Womanhood

Meet Mrs. Kiran Dembla, a homemaker cum qualified former classical singer cum mother cum mountaineer cum DJ cum professional photographer cum professional SIX PACK BODYBUILDER cum fitness trainer. #bodybuilder #fitness #indian
A mother of two children, Kiran Dembla, who battled against multiple blood clots in her brain about 14 years ago, enduring severe pain in her upper body, taking heavy dosage of intense medications as a part of treatment against clot, ... #woman #narishakti #beauty #feminity
meanwhile rapidly gaining weight under the side effect of medication, had a realisation one morning that she has gone deep into depression and soon will experience a mental breakdown ...
Read 22 tweets
Dec 6, 2020
Yet one more reason to reject those anti Hindu/anti Sanatani/anti Vedic so called (trad/tradcells/pseudo trad) Pandits & guardian of Dharma, who believe women don’t have right to study Vedas 👇:-
#Vedas #RigVeda #Hinduism #Hindu #SanatanDharma #Women
Rig Veda 1.164.41 (1st Mandal, 164th Sukta, 41st Mantra) says :-

गौ॒रीर्मि॑माय सलि॒लानि॒ तक्ष॒त्येक॑पदी द्वि॒पदी॒ सा चतु॑ष्पदी।
अ॒ष्टाप॑दी॒ नव॑पदी बभू॒वुषी॑ स॒हस्रा॑क्षरा पर॒मे व्यो॑मन् ॥
Word-Meaning: -
हे स्त्री-पुरुषो ! जो (एकपदी) एक वेद का अभ्यास करनेवाली वा (द्विपदी) दो वेद जिसने अभ्यास किये वा (चतुष्पदी) चार वेदों की पढ़ानेवाली वा (अष्टापदी) चार वेद और चार उपवेदों की विद्या से युक्ता वा (नवपदी) चार वेद, चार उपवेद और व्याकरणादि शिक्षायुक्त..
Read 25 tweets
Dec 4, 2020
Mini-#Thread on some comparisons between #Indians and #Chinese according to the travel memoirs of one of the earliest Arab merchants, Sulaiman, in Akhbar Al-Sin wa’l Hind dated 851 CE :-
#History #India #Bharat #China #Medieval #science #astronomy #medicine
On Dharma (religion), science, medicine, transmigration of soul after death, philosophy and astronomy:-
“The Chinese have no science (‘ ilm). Their religion originated in India; they assert that it were the Indians who procured their idols for them, and that they are the people who possess religion. The inhabitants of both the countries believe in metempsychosis (transmigration),..
Read 19 tweets
Dec 3, 2020
#Thread (3/3) on what Francois Bernier (1620-1688 CE), French physician, in service of Dara Shikoh & Aurangzeb, writes abt the bountiful produce of Kashmir and its intricate handicrafts & other products :-
#History #KashyapkaKashmir #India #Bharat #Kashmir #pasmeena
#handicraft ImageImageImage
Francois Bernier writes the following about the different produces of Kashmir :- Image
“The merchants who every year travel from mountain to mountain to collect the fine wool with which shawls are manufactured, all agree in saying that between all the mountains still dependent upon Kachemire there are many fine stretches of country.... ImageImage
Read 25 tweets
Dec 1, 2020
#Thread (2/3) on what Francois Bernier (1620-1688 CE), French physician, who was in service of Dara Shikoh & Aurangzeb, writes about the foundation of Kashmir as per Nilamat Purana, about its enchanting beauty & his visit to a temple dedicated to Sun God in Kashmir :-
According to Francois Bernier, like any other visitor earlier,

“Kashmir surpasses in beauty all that my warm imagination had anticipated.”
Read 46 tweets
Nov 30, 2020
#Thread (1/2) on what different foreign travelers, monks, missionaries etc recorded about Kashmir, the paradise on Earth since ancient times.
#History #KashyapkaKashmir #India #Bharat #Kashmir #Kaseer #Kashyap
1a)Hieun Tsiang (Yuan Chwang), (602-664 CE), the Chinese traveller, says the following about the natural produces from Kashmir :-
“....The flowers and plants, the fruits and trees are of different kinds, and have distinct names. It would be difficult to enumerate all the kinds of fruit…
Read 38 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(