(Thread) Changing MAGA minds
The coronavirus could throw a wrench into the Fox-Trump-Koch-Murdoch-GOP propaganda machine by demonstrating:
🔹how the lies hurt people, including MAGA people, and
🔹why a well-funded functioning government is necessary.
The coronavirus could throw a wrench into the Fox-Trump-Koch-Murdoch-GOP propaganda machine by demonstrating:
🔹how the lies hurt people, including MAGA people, and
🔹why a well-funded functioning government is necessary.
1/ Until now, the Trump-FOX-GOP willingly embraced Trump's lies because they knew the lies destroyed and they wanted to destroy.
If you’re a new follower, see my Slate article:
slate.com/news-and-polit…
There are, however, limits to what the Fox-Trump-GOP wants to destroy.
If you’re a new follower, see my Slate article:
slate.com/news-and-polit…
There are, however, limits to what the Fox-Trump-GOP wants to destroy.
2/ They want to destroy and dismantle the federal government to return to the glorious 1920s when (white) men had almost complete personal liberty.
But they don’t want their stock portfolio wiped out and they don’t want their family members to die from avoidable causes.
But they don’t want their stock portfolio wiped out and they don’t want their family members to die from avoidable causes.
3/ Trump's problems are:
🔹It’s provable that he made the situation worse
🔹the crises will harm the wealthy and privileged, and
🔹this is a genuine crisis and leaders like Trump are only good at handling manufactured crises. For what I mean by that see:
🔹It’s provable that he made the situation worse
🔹the crises will harm the wealthy and privileged, and
🔹this is a genuine crisis and leaders like Trump are only good at handling manufactured crises. For what I mean by that see:
4/ A manufactured crisis allows the leader to select the crisis that benefit him. An example is the “invasion” of migrants at the border. He can whip up rage in his followers.
A real crisis causes myth and lies to collide with reality in a way that Trump is unprepared to handle.
A real crisis causes myth and lies to collide with reality in a way that Trump is unprepared to handle.
5/ Now for the difference between coronavirus and sadopopulism.
Sadopopulism is the way 21st century fascists obtain both wealth and power: They enact policies that hurt their own constituents while enriching themselves.
If you’re a new follower, see 👇
Sadopopulism is the way 21st century fascists obtain both wealth and power: They enact policies that hurt their own constituents while enriching themselves.
If you’re a new follower, see 👇
6/ An example of sadopopulism is tax cuts for the rich. Ordinary people are harmed. Oligarchs are enriched.
Fox viewers believe they benefit from tax cuts for the rich because decades of propaganda persuaded them that trickle down economics works, and that all taxes are bad.
Fox viewers believe they benefit from tax cuts for the rich because decades of propaganda persuaded them that trickle down economics works, and that all taxes are bad.
7/ Coronavirus is different: It harms the people at the top by depleting their wealth.
It offers no advantage to ordinary MAGA people: They can't cheer while their "fearless leader" does battle with their enemies.
It just kills them and causes financial hardship.
It offers no advantage to ordinary MAGA people: They can't cheer while their "fearless leader" does battle with their enemies.
It just kills them and causes financial hardship.
8/ It proves that decades of weakening the federal government, and years of trying to eliminating health care was a stupid idea.
latimes.com/politics/story…
latimes.com/politics/story…
9/ The Trump-FOX-GOP will attempt to rewrite history and persuade people that Trump was onto the problem before anyone, and the outbreak is the fault of Democrats.
Our job is to fight hard against this kind of disinformation.
Our job is to fight hard against this kind of disinformation.
10/ This crisis, because of its nature, offers a rare opportunity to reach MAGA people.
I stand by my advice not to argue on Twitter. Bots and Trolls are trying to wear you out. Don’t let them.
Sam (not his real name) posted this on Facebook👇
My husband engaged offline.
I stand by my advice not to argue on Twitter. Bots and Trolls are trying to wear you out. Don’t let them.
Sam (not his real name) posted this on Facebook👇
My husband engaged offline.
11/ Offline is important.
The fact which that brought Sam round was this one:
marketwatch.com/story/trump-on…
This got to Sam.
Sam was not appalled by children in cages or attempts to cut affordable care, but this really got to him.
The fact which that brought Sam round was this one:
marketwatch.com/story/trump-on…
This got to Sam.
Sam was not appalled by children in cages or attempts to cut affordable care, but this really got to him.
12/ I believe this got to him because it shows Trump willing to lie and let people die as long as it makes him look better.
And Jack realized his family could suffer.
After the discussion, Sam said, “I’m not a Republican. I’m independent.” Until then, he was Republican.
And Jack realized his family could suffer.
After the discussion, Sam said, “I’m not a Republican. I’m independent.” Until then, he was Republican.
13/ Sam isn't a bad guy, and isn't a hardcore cultist.
He is just so overwhelmed with information that he can’t sort it out.
He said he watches both CNN and FOX in an attempt to get to the truth but—no surprise to —FOX persuades him.
Well, it's easy to make lies compelling.
He is just so overwhelmed with information that he can’t sort it out.
He said he watches both CNN and FOX in an attempt to get to the truth but—no surprise to —FOX persuades him.
Well, it's easy to make lies compelling.
14/ The liar, unconstrained by facts, can tell more absorbing tale.
“Noise” is a propaganda technique that destroys the truth by crowding the waves with so much information that people can't sort out truth from lies.
Eventually they conclude that truth is unknowable.
“Noise” is a propaganda technique that destroys the truth by crowding the waves with so much information that people can't sort out truth from lies.
Eventually they conclude that truth is unknowable.
14/ Noise was what Steve Bannon meant by this👇
We will never reach the hardcore cultists.
Hardcore cultists are people genuinely prefer what sociologist Max Weber calls the authority of personality over rule of law.
We will never reach the hardcore cultists.
Hardcore cultists are people genuinely prefer what sociologist Max Weber calls the authority of personality over rule of law.
15/ polisci2.ucsd.edu/foundation/doc…
Rule of law and democracy are messy and chaotic and require compromise.
A strongman leader seems to offer advantages.
That's why some cultist will pretend to believe even when they know it's a lie. They prefer Trump's lies to the alternative.
Rule of law and democracy are messy and chaotic and require compromise.
A strongman leader seems to offer advantages.
That's why some cultist will pretend to believe even when they know it's a lie. They prefer Trump's lies to the alternative.
16/ The alternative is liberal democracy 👇and compromise.
Those MAGA people who are reachable may learn from this pandemic that:
🔹We need a functioning government.
🔹Trump’s lies and the GOP’s systematic dismantling of the government will hurt them.
Those MAGA people who are reachable may learn from this pandemic that:
🔹We need a functioning government.
🔹Trump’s lies and the GOP’s systematic dismantling of the government will hurt them.
17/ I think for a lot of trolls and MAGA people, calling themselves "independent" is a way to encourage you to engage. It's like posing as a Bernie supporter.
We know Sam well. For him, it was a big step. He was actually distancing himself.
We know Sam well. For him, it was a big step. He was actually distancing himself.
Yup.
Here's an example of flooding the zone and stoking outrage to prevent people from focusing on the real issue: Lack of testing because of Trump's administrative incompetence.
Make no mistake: These are effective propaganda techniques.
The best antidote is to educate people.
Make no mistake: These are effective propaganda techniques.
The best antidote is to educate people.
This thread is here as a blog post: terikanefield-blog.com/changing-maga-…
