Let's say we give Trump the money and we build a wall 30 feet tall, 2000 miles long. Doesn't matter how, doesn't matter what it costs, don't worry about the details.
Build the wall, right?
1/
I'm saying: we build Trump's wall. 30 feet high, 2000 miles long.
2/
The US/Mexico border is 1954 miles long. Currently, about 700 miles is fenced in some fashion.
Meaning a bit more than 1200 miles isn't.
Why?
3/
So, if you build this wall, 30 feet high, 2000 miles long, 1200+ miles of it would STILL traverse remote territory. Follow?
4/
5/
You don't need to take my word for this, you can research the effectiveness of such barriers from the Great Wall of China to the Berlin Wall, from Hadrian's Wall to the West Bank Barrier.
6/
Oh, right. The West Bank Barrier, the wall which divides Israel from Palestine. It WORKS, you say.
It does. BUT it's not just a wall, it's a multi-layered defense system. Barbed wire, anti-sniper concrete wall, vehicle ditches, electronic systems, patrols.
7/
The American version would have to be 3 times as long and even more expensive.
8/
And the ONLY way a such a barrier works is with constant monitoring, constant patrolling. Because otherwise, as I mentioned up above, all you need to defeat it is a ladder and some time.
9/
10/
The French spent enormous resources to fortify their border. But once in place, those resources were fixed. They could not move or be used elsewhere.
When the Nazis did a rapid end run around the fortifications...
11/
By its very nature, a wall is fixed in position. Meaning, the defenses and resources of a wall are only useful AT THE WALL.
12/
Like a prison.
13/
Any unattended section, any blind spot will be found, and exploited.
14/
Those seeking refuge in the US are unlikely to storm the border with a Blitzkrieg of tanks -- and if they were, WE WOULDN'T BUILD A WALL ANYWAY because the US military doesn't fight from fixed positions.
15/
16/
You will NEVER get a return on your investment.
17/
if you have to patrol the entire length in real time ANYWAY
if you have to monitor the cameras and sensors and drones ANYWAY
if you have to counter any breach anywhere anytime ANYWAY
THEN YOU DON'T NEED A PHYSICAL WALL.
18/
It would have to be a complex system of technology and human beings where the physical wall itself is the LEAST part, its defenses fixed and inflexible, unable to adapt to changing circumstance.
19/
And without a wall, those systems become much more flexible, mobile, unpredictable, and adaptable.
And cheaper. Vastly cheaper.
20/
A simple wall is a simple solution for simple minds and worthless for anything else.
21/21
THAT, right there, is the joker in the deck.
Build this wall, 2000 miles long, 30 feet high. Spend billions.
And it doesn't work. Or doesn't work ENOUGH. Because it won't.
People still get in.
22/
They'll go over your wall, under it, through it. To justify the money you spent, you'll have to spend MORE. More security people, more technology, more concrete, more barbed wire, more guns, more land.
And people will STILL get in.
23/
They'll go around your wall, risking their lives on the ocean. So you'll have to patrol that, in force. You'll have to guard the coast, walk the beaches on foot, put up air patrols, more technology, build more walls.
And still, they'll get in.
24/
They'll get in.
Even if they don't, you'll THINK that they are. They're STILL getting in, you'll believe.
25/
It's the easiest form of power, the simplest way to manipulate the rudest of minds. THEM. THEY'RE getting in. THEY'RE taking your jobs, raping, murdering, stealing YOUR democracy. THEM.
We gotta do more.
26/
You built the walls, you patrol the beaches and the skies. But it's not enough, those in power tell you.
THEY are still getting in. THEY are here. Oh yes THEY are. Who else would be causing these problems?
We gotta do more.
27/
Don't you want to be safe? Don't you want your kids to be safe? Of course you do.
We gotta do MORE.
28/
You need proper identification.
And then we'll need some sort of police force to check those papers...
We have to be safe, don't we?
29/
That's how this goes.
That's how this goes EVERY time. It's never enough. You can never be sure. You can never be safe. Those who thrive on this kind of power, the power of fear, they need you to be afraid. And so it will NEVER be enough. EVER.
30/
31/31