,
13 tweets,
3 min read
Read on Twitter
To be precise, before the middle of the last century, there was no such thing as a Palestinian people that identified as such (outside of Jews before 1948.) They really are a made up people. Feel free to prove me wrong with links to articles/books about them before 1940.
I understand how saying these facts makes you angry, but I consider falsifying history to be a pretty big problem as well.
I've spent hours researching Palestinian history and culture. Outside Nablus soap and Bethlehem costumes - which were local, not national - almost nada.
I've spent hours researching Palestinian history and culture. Outside Nablus soap and Bethlehem costumes - which were local, not national - almost nada.
And yes, I've seem more modern re-writings of history to find a unique Palestinian cuisine, etc. It's a joke and you know it. There was Levantine culture, Egyptian culture and so forth, but no Palestinian culture.
Obviously there were Arabs living in Palestine. No one claims otherwise. But they identified more with their clans and towns than with anything called "Palestine."
Of course, most prominent Palestinian families proudly trace their family trees from elsewhere, especially Arabia.
Of course, most prominent Palestinian families proudly trace their family trees from elsewhere, especially Arabia.
So while @YousefMunayyer rants and raves, he knows what I am saying is true. So his only defense is anger, because most Westerners cringe when Arabs freak out and they'll agree to anything to avoid a fight.
But I'm Jewish and I know my history. I'm not cowed that easily.
But I'm Jewish and I know my history. I'm not cowed that easily.
@YousefMunayyer Just like the modern myth of how well Arabs treated their Jewish neighbors, the myth of an ancient Palestinian people is just that - a myth.
Nowadays, I admit they exist - mostly because their Arab "brethren" treated them like crap and didn't let them become citizens after 1948
Nowadays, I admit they exist - mostly because their Arab "brethren" treated them like crap and didn't let them become citizens after 1948
As you know, most weren't "expelled" from Israel but fled out of fear, thinking that they could integrate with their Arab neighbors like they had so many other times in history. This time was different - the Arabs decided to "other" them, supposedly for their own good.
A joke.
A joke.
Has there ever been a poll of how many Palestinians would happily accept citizenship in the UAE or Lebanon or Egypt if they could? No because people like you don't want the truth to be known. You'd rather they remain stateless.
For the good of a made-up peoplehood.
For the good of a made-up peoplehood.
No, I don't hate the Palestinian Arabs. They are a tragic example of how the honor/shame culture would rather use people as pawns against Israel (the ultimate shame) rather than treat them as human.
Why are they the only 7 decade old refugee problem in history?
Why are they the only 7 decade old refugee problem in history?
Because unlike EVERY OTHER REFUGEE IN HISTORY, Palestinian "leaders" and Arab leaders decided that it was in their interest to keep them stateless forever or until Israel is destroyed.
That thinking persists today.
Calling it out is simply stating the truth.
That thinking persists today.
Calling it out is simply stating the truth.
Keeping the Palestinians in misery is a conscious Arab strategy since the 1950s. Everyone knows this. But mentioning it publicly is practically taboo. Luckily, the primary sources are still easy to find.
Arabs all know this, but shame forces them to push the issue to the Jews.
Arabs all know this, but shame forces them to push the issue to the Jews.
I don't expect Munayyer to respond with any facts, because he knows I'm right. And that the facts are his enemy.
But I'm not going to stop telling the truth, and backing them up with evidence.
Thanks for reading.
But I'm not going to stop telling the truth, and backing them up with evidence.
Thanks for reading.
Thread continues here (I seem to have broken it...)
