1. It misrepresents the facts.
2. It's a blatant populist device, and populism ends in bad places.
THREAD
constitution-unit.com/2019/11/05/why…
For months it's been thought that Boris Johnson wanted an election on those terms.
Now the election campaign has started, politicians and media should steer clear of this framing.
But the rhetoric from the Johnson administration has been more frequent, and far worse.
There are various examples, but to cite just one...
When the Commons returned, far from being contrite, Attorney General Geoffrey Cox suggested that "This parliament is a dead parliament… [that] has no moral right to sit".
This framing was deeply disingenuous, for two key reasons.
It defeated the programme motion, but this offered just 3 days scrutiny, which most experts (see below) judged woefully inadequate.
Instead Johnson demanded the election that he had clearly wanted all along (despite claiming that he didn't).
@PhilipHammondUK put it nicely:
Pro-Brexit Conservatives - including Johnson and several others in his Cabinet - repeatedly voted against Theresa May's deal (see below).
constitution-unit.com/2019/10/02/whi…
Boris Johnson withdrew his after just three days.
Going into an election on a message of "parliament versus people" is thus opportunistic.
It is disreputable, and even sinister, for two reasons.
Populism is essentially anti-political, seeking to set people against elites.
Diversity of opinion is ignored, as is the complexity politicians face in responding to that opinion. Political institutions are demonised.
A key feature is the undermining of democratic institutions, such as parliaments, and checks and balances, such as courts.
Eventually such institutions come under threat, as in Hungary and Turkey.
A legislature is central to any democracy. In fact, you cannot have a democracy without a functioning legislature.
But to function, the legislature relies on public support.
E.g. see the @HansardSociety Audit of Political Engagement.
This year's most worrying finding was support for a "strong leader willing to break the rules"
hansardsociety.org.uk/publications/r…
In times of crisis, responsible politicians should work to maintain & build trust in political institutions, not cynically drive trust down for short-term electoral gain.
@UKandEU @UCL_EI @psa_parl @StudyofParl @PSAAntipolitics @populismPSA @RoryStewartUK @CasMudde
constitution-unit.com/2019/11/05/why…