I have been arguing for a long time that the EU, and particularly the EPP, should stand up to Viktor Orbán, but I feel nevertheless conflicted on triggering #Article7 - let me explain. #Thread theguardian.com/commentisfree/…
1. Although triggering Article 7 does not mean kicking Hungary out of EU (more below), it is starting with the "nuclear option".
2. Orbán and Fidesz have been creating an "illiberal state" since regaining power in 2010. That is 8 years of undermining checks and balances, recreating institutions and filling them with cronies, and creating a kleptocracy on Russian model.
3. Yet, except for some weak resolutions, mostly concerned with economic freedom (i.e. bank and media ownership), the EU has done little to nothing to stop Orbán dismantling liberal democracy in Hungary.
4. Obviously, prime responsibility rests with @EPP , the political group that Fidesz belongs to. Its key politicians, most notably @JosephDaul and @ManfredWeber , have been instrumental in shielding Orbán from sanctions.
5. But even the "critical" voices with @EPPGroup - notably the "Northern parties", have been happy enough to take a wait and see approach, buying into the "at least inside EPP we have influence on him" narrative.
6. Clearly, this approach never worked. Orbán has changed the EPP more than that the EPP has changed Orbán!
7. As Orbán jumped on so-called "refugee crisis", becoming the most important radical right voice in EUrope", even challenging "Queen Europe" Angela Merkel, major EPP members rallied around him rather than standing up for real Christian democratic values.
8. As as media and politics convinced each other that nativists are "the people", Orbán's power grew, being the voice of "the Somewheres", berating the "out-of-touch" elites in Brussels (and Berlin). His electoral victories "proved" this.
9. The fact that these victories were created within an increasingly controlled political environment, with an exceptionally incompetent and corrupt "opposition", was barely noted.
10. Moreover, that part of the support was "bought" with government hand-outs just before the elections, was largely ignored -- even though some research shows this was more important than Fidesz' nativist campaign of fear.
11. The point is that these hand-outs are only possible because of lavish EU funding -- Hungary receives most EU money per inhabitant according to some studies. This is why EU in general, and EPP in particular, is complicit is Orbán's attack on liberal democracy in Hungary!
12. The EU should have sanctioned Hungary already years earlier. First, by holding back subsidies because of corrupt practices in distributing the money within Hungary. Second, for not complying with certain EU political regulations.
13. The @EPP should have suspended Fidesz membership and kicked them out if they wouldn't have changed their policies. Only then should we have triggered Article 7.
14. Call me a cynic, but my reading of the @EPP change of heart is this: they need to have this divisive issue off the agenda in the run-up to 2019 European elections. This was the best (only) way.
15. The vote means that EU and Hungary have to engage in "dialogue" to work out differences. This means that "things are in process" and no read decisions have to be taken. At same time @ManfredWeber can claim he stands for liberal democracy and be acceptable to both EPP camps.
16. Orbán doesn't loose anything concrete either, and can rail against Brussels and boost his nationalist credentials back home, while opposition is divided, because supporting Art.7 is "treason" while opposing it is supporting Fidesz.
17. At same time, he keeps pressuring EP by threatening to found new radical right group -- which is why he met with Salvini -- and hopes that Fidesz will do even better in 2019 (they will) and EPP will do worse (they probably will), thereby increasing relative power.
18. In addition, he will give his supporters within EPP (Daul and Weber) some small symbolic victories -- most notably signing contract with CEU, which will also get US off his back -- and they will use this to argue that keeping him within EPP works.
19. And then, after 2019 European elections, and with Weber as EC President, Article.7 procedure is either ended, because Hungary "cooperated", or voted down by Visegrad allies.
20. And Orbán will come out even stronger: either having successfully defied EU or having been absolved of all sins and been given the official seal of approval. #TheEnd
