WomenAotearoaNZ Profile picture
Apr 2 116 tweets 93 min read
#NZ This is a long thread on the issue of harassment & threats made against #WomenInLeadership, primarily #WomenInPolitics.

⬇️ Reviews incidents over time, highlights the danger & escalation of #misogyny & the real life consequences on the personal & our democratic institutions.
This thread is being woven, the week Michael Cruickshank was sentenced to jail in #NZ for threatening to blow our #WomanPrimeMinister’s head off & to “..wipe you off this f---planet”- Also arrested this week Richard Sivell who has allegedly been posting threatening messages.
Here you can take a look at #OnlineAbuse ~ ⬇️ is a really useful article by @shesource & @WMCLive that names online hostile behaviour, how it is that #Women are targeted, & explains why “online harassment exists on a continuum with offline violence”

womensmediacenter.com/speech-project…
#NZ Here, one of our major newspapers gave due attention to the vitriol directed at our women leaders ~ everyday. It’s significant for a few reasons. It’s front page recognition of what out #WomenLeaders face, it’s also highlighting the problem, rather than contributing to it.
#NZ & this is true “#Misogyny is not becoming normalised, it is normalised. It’s very much present and expanding in Aotearoa,” ~@sanjanah

stuff.co.nz/dominion-post/…
& it is prevalent everywhere there are #WomenLeaders & especially #WomenInPolitics

"I get called a whore, that I'm a slut, that I should put my tits away, that I'm unintelligent, that I'm an idiot, that I should go away and bake a cake instead..”

bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-…
In #Canada ‘Joanne Bernard recalls the shock she felt when she left Nova Scotia's non-profit sector to work in provincial politics, and suddenly became the target of the worst kind of online vitriol, including fat shaming and homophobic tirades’ cbc.ca/news/canada/ne…
In #Finland ‘A new report from the NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence, based in Latvia, has found that the Finnish government, headed by Prime Minister Sanna Marin, is overwhelmingly targeted by misogynistic #OnlineHarassmentpolitico.eu/article/sanna-…
In #Uganda ‘..there has been rising rates of online harassment targeting both high profile women as well as everyday users’ ndi.org/our-stories/im…
In #Zimbabwe ‘..the few female candidates have faced insults such as "slut" and accusations of sleeping around. #GenderBasedPrejudices are still rife in this southern African nation’ news24.com/News24/zim-ele…
In the #USA ‘Why it matters: As record numbers of American women are being elected to public office, their growing political power is being met with death & rape threats, sexist & racist abuse & online disinformation’

axios.com/women-politici…
In #Japan ‘…a fact of life for women who run for office in Japan, where female participation in politics is already among the lowest in the world’ theguardian.com/world/2021/oct…
All over our world..“Women in politics face an extraordinary amount of abuse on social media, partly just because they speak up, but also simply because they are women”

& Black, Asian & Minority Ethnic women MPs far more than their white colleagues. amnesty.org.uk/online-violenc…
Any #Woman who is in public office is a target for #OnlineAbuse for ‘choosing to participate in politics’

latimes.com/politics/00000…
We were ~again~ reminded in #NZ that “It is all part of a concerted effort to get women out of public leadership roles” ~ @zenpeacekeeper

“It’s about silencing women,” ~ @golrizghahraman

stuff.co.nz/national/polit…
& yes this ‘silencing effect’ is a threat to democracy.

‘Women who challenge the status quo..are facing an increasing amount of online abuse…threatened with physical violence, or..the subject of false narratives spread to discredit them’

msmagazine.com/2021/11/30/soc…
“Younger women & #LGBTQ+ #WomenInPolitics also face a heightened risk of abuse..”

“..gender-based violence against women politicians is a highly #misogynistic form of behaviour”

irishexaminer.com/opinion/commen…
“While straightforward examples of #abuse & #discrimination are easy to identify, categorise & quantify, tweets which include more subtle #microaggressions that position #women & minority MPs as unqualified & unwelcome in politics deserve attention” ⬇️

tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
“Around the world, online #ViolenceAgainstWomen is pervasive & endemic. Understanding its impact on women is fundamental to our understanding of the consequences for democracy”

“I would never ever, ever subject myself to that again”

cigionline.org/articles/when-…
Which brings us back again to #NZ where this week @SaraTempleton_ exposed a campaign of #misogynistic online trolling targeting #WomenInPolitics including herself a Christchurch city councillor, Cabinet minister & Wigram MP @Megan_Woods & Ilam Labour MP @sarah4ilam
It’s worth now, taking a moment to look at our history & a few ‘incidents’ in #NZ ~ & consider Seddon’s statue speaking ~ who resides on the front lawn of our parliament.

His & his fellow man’s sentiments of 1879 sound strangely familiar in 2022.
#NZ “…& includes a harrowing story of how death threats against her affected her young son. The other is being a woman at the top of politics. Would history have treated Jenny Shipley & Ruth Richardson differently if they were men? thespinoff.co.nz/politics/28-04…
#NZ ~ notable mentions of offensive material sent to #WomenInPolitics
#NZ "I've received death threats & abuse & seen my children have to deal with the relentless negativity & lies that are aimed at us through the media & social media alike” ~ Amy Adams in parliament.

nzherald.co.nz/nz/national-mp…
#NZ Again, in review "The culture of #bullying, #sexism, & belittling of #WomenMPs by male colleagues needs to stop. Threats of death, rape & violence to women MPs must not be tolerated, & where possible must be prosecuted"~@drjackieblue

stuff.co.nz/national/polit…
#NZ Harassment & targeting of #WomenEnteringPolitics.
From 2019. ⬇️
#NZ Lest we forget ~The Francis Review into #HarmfulBehaviour in Parliament. ~ with bullying & harassment widespread ~ which included 14 allegations of #SexualAssault

nzherald.co.nz/nz/francis-rev…
#NZ & #MeTooParliament a part of the bigger picture.
#NZ & it was beyond disappointing in 2015 to see of #WomenMembers thrown from the chamber for speaking up & to see our predominantly male parliament & pony tail pulling Prime Minister if the time trivialise #SexualAssault & #SexualHarassment

#NZ In review ~ our #WomenPoliticians being silenced.

“Order! Order! Order! No!” ~ then Speaker of The House @NZParliament

#NZ In Review ~ ‘In two cases, the MPs said #SexistBehaviour had convinced them not to seek re-election.’ ~ @Alisonmau

stuff.co.nz/national/polit…
#NZ "..Anybody in politics is expected to take it on the chin, & we largely do, but I don't think it's helpful in trying to curate a more collaborative, constructive, inclusive & accessible political landscape"~@_chloeswarbrick
#WomenInPoliticsOnlineAbuse

nzherald.co.nz/nz/green-mp-ch…
#NZ ~ BITCH ~ #WomenInPolitics

“This is a taster of what too many women have to deal with on the regular & something that aids in a little bit of healthy introspection”

thespinoff.co.nz/politics/14-01…
#NZ & where’s the support & concern from colleagues?

“Shame on you. Shame on you. Shame on you. I'm horrified that you are signal boosting this message after what has been revealed about threats to Golriz's physical safety this week…Shame on you” ~ @Sharkpatu’s response to ⬇️
In Review ~ 2018 #NZ Political Studies association hears about politicians' #HarassmentExperiences

"Labour’s Ruth Dyson spoke about receiving death threats..Golriz Ghahraman..remembered someone saying: “It’s time to load our shotguns.”

wgtn.ac.nz/news/2018/12/w…
#NZ 2019 “..the threat level..escalated following an interview where Act MP David Seymour said she was a menace to freedom..Ghahraman said the decision for her to have a security escort was also as a result a Newshub investigation into #WhiteSupremacy..”

nzherald.co.nz/nz/green-mp-go…
#NZ ~ In Review 2019 #WomenInPolitics “ Ghahraman said threats of violence had begun almost as soon as she announced her candidacy for parliament. That escalated after the Christchurch terror attacks”

thespinoff.co.nz/politics/23-05…
#NZ ~ #WomenInPolitics Reviewed.

Indeed ⬇️
#NZ ~ Current Opposition Spokesperson for Education Michael Woodhouse didn’t see this as a burning issue of the day ~ but today, again, it seems quite relevant & #Toxic.

#WomenInPolitics

thespinoff.co.nz/politics/04-07…
#NZ#OnlineHarassment traumatises, silences, and affects those who have the most to contribute to public discourse” ~ @michelle_duff

stuff.co.nz/life-style/106…
#NZ & lest we forget more from the misogynistic protagonists that create narratives of our #WomenInParliament as ‘dangerous’ & just how dangerous that actually is. ~ Media have a role to play in our dehumanisation & the potential for threats made against us.
#NZ ~ Another demeaning attack on our #WomenInParliament & a clear rebuttal with truth says it all ~ thank you @2TAPU
#NZ & the attacks as we know, come also from #women who have deeply internalised the #WhiteSupremacistPatriarchy & assist in fighting his violent battles.

⬇️ Written by a woman about one of our #WomenLeaders receiving death & rape threats.
#NZ In Review ~ & #MediaMen & their #EveryDaySexism & #Misogyny contributing to the climate of disrespect & unsafe lives. They are accountable.

newshub.co.nz/home/politics/…
#NZ ~ Grade A+ here. ~ We see you Sean.

Many of our #WomenJournalists have been writing about the attacks on our #WomenLeaders for years.
#NZ In Review ~ #Misogyny directed at our #WomenInPolitics

"I have a sense of deja vu: the same forces of reaction carped throughout my time as a leader” ~ @HelenClarkNZ

odt.co.nz/news/election-…
#NZ ‘Helen Clark & Dame Jenny Shipley were both interviewed at length for @radionz The 9th Floor series.
…Asked by Guyon Espiner about #GenderBasedAbuse, Clark said that "nasty stuff" was a feature of some of her political career’

nzherald.co.nz/nz/helen-clark…
#NZ In Review 2017: ‘Bill English once rode to parliament holding a sign saying; "The mad cow shouldn't have signed" about then Prime Minister Helen Clark.’ ~ @michelle_duff

#MisogynyInTheHouse

stuff.co.nz/life-style/970…
#NZ So from the above ⬆️ we can assume it was political expediency that the then, PM Bill English said he would rule out a coalition with the Opportunities Party if its leader held an attitude "outside acceptable boundaries". Who’s boundaries Bill?

nzherald.co.nz/nz/storm-erupt…
#NZ & now, a few notes on the thread from people in NZ who see the threats & misogyny.
Indeed.
#WomenInLeadership ~ Let’s raise our expectations
#NZ “..if we could all just start taking it seriously…” @kirsty_johnston
#NZ ~ “..There needs to be a more robust process..” ~ @Te_Taipo
#NZ ~ remember??
#NZ ~ The silencing ~ Thank you @sacraparental
#NZ ~ When our PM rightfully took her feeding ‘baby’ to the @UN
#NZ The emboldened feeling of entitlement to engage in harassment of #WomenInPublicLife
#NZ ~ Tolerated & amplified.
#NZ “According to Netsafe, sharing nude or nearly nude photos of someone without their consent could be an offence under the #HarmfulDigitalCommunicationsAct

Article here: stuff.co.nz/national/polit…
#NZ We should remember what happened to one of our male MPs when he tried to express some remorse for what happens to #Women in Aotearoa.

The then ponytail pulling Prime Minister John Key emasculated David & wasted the opportunity by playing #NotAllMen

stuff.co.nz/national/10232…
#NZ ~& back to #WomenLeaders as witches

“It hardly warrants dignifying by mentioning, but the piece’s fun-time-banter suggestion that the gender of the PM might have some mysterious demonic sway over the fortunes of the All Blacks is obviously bullshit”

thespinoff.co.nz/media/22-10-20…
#NZ “This plays on the traditional trope of woman as evil seductress. From there it’s a short leap to the conspiracy theories that depict Ardern as part of an evil international cabal.”

An insightful read by @suzewilsonnz a Senior Lecturer @MasseyUni

theconversation.com/from-pretty-co…
#NZ “What they’re really doing is standing up against equality of opportunity…standing up against women having a chance to have our say & to influence the direction of the country..” ~ @suzewilsonnz

#WomenInLeadership

Hear more ⬇️ on @ThePanelRNZ

rnz.co.nz/national/progr…
#NZ ~ a clear & established trend of conservative ideas about the kind of leadership roles #Women should have are on the rise. As measured here in the @ncwnz Gender Attitudes Survey 20221.

genderequal.nz/wp-content/upl…
#NZ It’s Sean & Chris doing their bit for #Women & #WomenInLeadership. ~ there’s a pattern that needs to be recognised.
Let’s head over the ditch to #Australia & see how we represent..& who rates.

‘That Woman’ ~ ‘Sock down her throat’

#WomenInPolitics
& if you'd like to reminisce the strength of @JuliaGillard speech in #Australian parliament watch full speech here:

& hear the former Prime Minister discuss that #MisogynySpeech here: ~“with a cool sense of anger” #WomenInPolitics
& in #Australia 2022 ~ #WomenInLeadership

“She should stay in the brothel where she clearly belongs." 
"Being hated is sometimes very well deserved."
"Drop dead, you dirty dog c***."
"Die, Nazi scum."

‘Abuse relentless & normalised’

abc.net.au/news/2022-02-1…
#Australia ~ From 2018.
#WomenInPolitics ~ IN Review #MoreWomen ~ #IAmANastyWomanBecause . These misogynistic comments are discriminatory & contribute to Violence Against Women #VAW & a weakening of #democracy.
Classy #AustralianMedia, describing a ‘cat fight’ among #Women rightfully challenging for a political seat ~ their rightful seat at the table of politics.

#Media & #Misogyny ~ needs to be held to account #LanguageMatters
Just regular notes sent to #WomenInPolitics ~ this to an Australian Green Senator.
Let’s pop over the the #USA for a journey down misogyny lane for #WomenRunningForOffice

The #Sexist & #Racist comments read allowed. From 2018.
Each of these #WomenInPolitics have, in turn, faced horrific threats to their safety. & egregiously encouraged by the #PredatorInChief trump.
#USA ‘Omar, a Somali-American & one of two #MuslimWomen in Congress, later blasted Republicans over the “anti-Muslim” poster.  

No wonder why I am on the “Hitlist” of a domestic terrorist & “Assassinate Ilhan Omar” is written on my local gas stations”

thehill.com/homenews/state…
#USA 2019 - Tried & tested pursuits|mechanisms of the #patriarchy declaring a woman’s mind as broken & bewitched whilst centring the blame of their actions upon her. #WomenInPolitics ~ this is dangerous.

thehill.com/homenews/senat…
& here where a #WomanInPolitics has her narrative spun & twisted so she appears to be all that is wrong & must be destroyed.

Another tried & consistently used process against #WomenInLeadership
Combat lies against our #WomenInPolitics ~ they can cost lives.

“When we see lies call it out. Then keep calling it out” ~ @LillianTahuri
This, from the media in #Australia in 2019 ~ this is dangerous.
This is the same man who once called for then #Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard to be dropped out to sea in a chaff bag." - #WomenLeadersUnderThreat
#GenderBasedPoliticalViolence is seen throughout #LatinAmerica, particularly in Mexico, where 19 female candidates were killed and 118 were attacked ahead of the July elections. ~ 2018

arkansasonline.com/news/2018/aug/…
2018 ~ #MarielleFranco, 38, was a groundbreaking #politician who had become a voice for disadvantaged people in the teeming favelas that are home to almost one-quarter of #RioDeJaneiro’s population..”

#WomenInPolitics

theguardian.com/world/2018/mar…
#WomenInPolitics - 'The Assassination' - An investigation into the death of one of the world’s best known politicians – #Pakistan’s Benazir Bhutto.

bbc.co.uk/programmes/p05…
#WomenInPolitics ~ IN Review "A charity set up in the name of murdered MP Jo Cox has highlighted the “abhorrent” abuse aimed at female MPs which has prompted several to step down from Parliament." 2019.

mirror.co.uk/news/politics/…
“The investigation revealed evidence that female figures receive proportionately more abuse than their male counterparts - & that a significant proportion of it takes the form of #misogynistic & #violent anti-female vitriol” 2019

#WomenInPolitics

bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-tre…
“..Mair stepped out of a shadow as Cox walked towards the library where she was due to hold a surgery for constituents. He raised his sawn-off rifle & shot her. Then he pulled her to the ground…& stabbed her repeatedly with his dagger”

theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/n…
#ViolenceAainstWomenInPolitics ~ 2022 ~ A moral & ethical failure.

‘Women today occupy 26.1 percent of parliamentary seats globally, compared to 13.1 per cent in 2000, according to the Inter Parliamentary Union (IPU).

news.un.org/en/story/2022/…
2018 ~ #WomenInPolitics ‘..most women reported psychological rather than physical abuse: a daily ritual of #sexism & #misogyny, sometimes from family members as well as from the community & political colleagues’

theguardian.com/politics/2018/…
#NZ "The story is complex, involving harmful behaviour by & between staff, managers, Members, media & the public."

Background:In 2018 House Speaker announced an independent external review into #bullying & #harassment of staff at @NZParliament

nzfvc.org.nz/news/independe…
‘Online abuse against #politicians is often misunderstood as inevitable..the gendered & racialized nature of the phenomenon has received increasing policy attention..#women..disproportionately targeted by online abuse & disinformation attacks’ .2020.

carnegieendowment.org/2020/11/30/tac…
“An emerging body of research has begun to examine the #GenderedDimensions of violence & harassment directed against politicians…violence is not limited to physical violence, & that attacks against politicians can instead take a wide variety of forms”

cambridge.org/core/journals/…
#UK “Our analysis found that 3 per cent of all Tweets sent to women MPs between 1 January and 8 June 2017 were identified as abusive amounting to a total of 25,688 abusive Tweets out of 900,223 total Tweets” #WomenInPolitics

onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/ne…
#NZ how did our #WomenLeaders fair in our General Election you ask…
#NZ “..not something that goes away when you log off. Imagine getting #DeathThreats or #rape threats when you open an app..particular danger of #OnlineAbuse is how fast it can proliferate..a barrage of targeted hate in a matter of minutes"~ @AmnestyNZ

amnesty.org.nz/amnesty-reveal…
#NZ ~ From @AmnestyNZ & @amnesty research in 2017.

"Around a quarter (24%) of women surveyed who said that they had experienced abuse said that it had made them fear for their family’s safety."
‘A holistic discourse around feminist self-defense & self & collective care does not distinguish between online/off-line activism..women, transgender & gender non-conforming..experience high levels of violence both in real life & in #DigitalSpaces

openglobalrights.org/embedding-digi…
“..amid this reckoning, relatively little attention has been paid to the way in which #misogyny also intersects with misinformation & violent extremism in the online world—& why addressing it head on is not only a priority for securing #WomensRights..’

brookings.edu/techstream/gen…
‘Guidance..focuses primarily on #WomenInPolitics but it likewise applies to #ViolenceAgainstWomen in public life more broadly..perpetrated against #WomenHumanRightsDefenders, #journalists, those active in civil society & in other areas of public life’

unwomen.org/en/digital-lib…
#NZ This report presents the results of a CWP New Zealand survey on the experiences of #WomenParliamentarians & the @NZParliament as an institution. 2018.

parliament.nz/media/5466/sex…
‘Political violence targeting women’ #PVTW

2021. ~ This report analyzes the expanded data to unpack key trends in violence targeting #WomenInPolitics. #Global

reliefweb.int/report/world/v…
& a note on a part of the ‘why’ of the misinformation train for #WomenInPolitics
#NZ PM is emerging as the progressive antithesis to right-wing strongmen like Trump, Orban & Modi, whose careers thrive on illiberal, anti-Muslim & anti-immigrant rhetoric"

nytimes.com/2019/03/19/opi…
‘No matter one’s political affiliation, it is worth noting that ridicule has been a strategy of #SilencingWomenInPolitics for centuries’ blog.oup.com/2019/01/in-the…
Silence from some quarters will be required. #WomenInPolitics
@profsarahchilds ‘what’s preventing #Women from entering parliament on @ninetonoon

Breaking down the Barriers in #Politics

‘Women suffer from the male politician norm..can you be a good politician & still be considered a ‘good woman’

rnz.co.nz/audio/player?a…
Where’s the wave ~ #WomenInPolitics ~ #Australia

#WomenInPolitics ~ #SexistFilth

“Real men don’t insult & threaten #Women, they don’t #SlutShame them, & they don’t attack them & make them feel bullied in their #workplace

That’s all for this topic on #Violence & #Harassment of #WomenInPolitics today.

What we know is that we have the good island nation we have today due to #Women’s participation in #politics.

This thread will be woven further with some reasoning & more thoughts at a later date.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with WomenAotearoaNZ

WomenAotearoaNZ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @WeavingHouse

Mar 26, 2019
"This position, which is pure sophistry illuminates just how much the NRA does not know, or care to know, about the deadly reality of women" Telling a woman to "just get a gun" is as simplistic and victim-blaming as telling her to "just leave." womensmediacenter.com/news-features/…
Read 14 tweets
Sep 23, 2018
The following thread contains articles on White Supremacy & #Women's role in its continued existence ~ Reads for each of us think about our role in extinguishing this most pernicious blight for good. #WeHaveThePower #MyFeminismWillBeIntersectionalOrItWillBeBullshit
"... but white women have historically enabled racism even if it came with the cost of misogyny -huffingtonpost.com/entry/it-wasnt…
"We know that 53 percent of white women voted for Donald Trump. We know that some white women are so blinded by their privilege, their racism, and a patriarchal system that insists their lives as wives and mothers are “precious” .." bitchmedia.org/article/mother…
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(