Discover and read the best of Twitter Threads about #CAA2019

Most recents (24)

1) The survey without asking papers which is being referred here is NPR & not NRC. The "buddhijivi" mixed up 2 different exercises here. The NPR exercise doesn't have to do anything with citizenship. It's meant to count RESIDENTS of India & NOT CITIZENS of India.
So, the question of marking somebody "doubtful" does not arise.
2) By saying that just because of a person's religion, a 'D' will be marked, this man is trying to create 'dar ka mahaul". I would love to know his argument supporting this ha-te ful thought.
3) He adds that
before Modi govt., there used to be no Birth Certificate & just birth used to be THE proof.
Bro! I was born in the yr when BJP was just 3 yr old officially & I've a birth certificate.😀
4) Onus of proving citizenship, as per the criterion defined in the Citizenship Act 1955
Read 8 tweets
Just attended a meeting on #CAA2019 in Chennai with APShah as Chief Guest. Most moving presentaion was by @rohini_mohan on Assam NRC. I could not hold my tears when she showed a pic of two young sisters - 3 and 5 yrs- taken to Detention Centre. Their family declared illegal +
Their neighbour for long years with whom father spent childhood took pity and approached HC to contest Tribunal judgement. HC ruled in favour. Family including 2 sisters released after 9 years. She showed before and after pics. You cannot but cry +
it was the great INC that was in power. How did we allow our State to take away our children?

One point that comes across is that this is in the making for a long time. 2003 of Vajpayee regime is the biggest culprit. And UPA built on this the Aadhar system +
Read 5 tweets
Public discussion on CAA, 2019-NRC-NPR to begin shortly at the Music Academy, Chennai.

Justice (Retd) AP Shah, N Ram, Chairman of The Hindu Publishing Group, Legal Scholar, Usha Ramanathan and Rohini Mohan, Journalist to speak at the event.
@nramind : I don't think we need to exaggerate this movement (referring to Anti-CAA demonstrations).... against this unjust and indeed an outrageous piece of legislation...

There is no question that the students have come to the fore in this movement, says @nramind

#CAA_NRC_NPR #CAA_NRCProtests #CAA_NRC_Protests
Read 39 tweets
1/13 ठीक @anu1122 बेहन लेकीन ये संदेश थोडा लेट हो गया. क्यो शगुफ्ता @shufta20 बेहन (Please don’t be apologist, you are also a woman) ठीक हे ना?
Below are mere quotations "NOT MY OPINION" SOURCES mentioned at end. @myogiadityanath
#CAA_NPR_Protest #ShaheenBaghProtests #CAA2019
2/13 Quotes Not My Opinions Sources at the end

1.Women are Inferior to Men
2.Women are Half Intelligent
3.Women are Weak
4.Women are Stupid
5.Women are Crooked
6.Women are Wicked
7.Women are Toys
8.Women Lack Gratitude
9.Women are Hypocrites (for divorce)
3/13 Quotes Not My Opinions Sources at the end

10.Women are Evil Omen
11.Women Annul Prayers
12.Women are Dogs
13.Women are Devils
14.Women (Most) Are Destined for Hell
15.Women Value Half
16.Women are failed Rulers
17.Women Annul Prayers
Read 16 tweets
Citizenship Amendment Act: Supreme Court to take up for hearing a batch of over 140 petitions concerning the controversial CAA today. #CAA #CitizenshipAmendmentAct #CAA_2019 #SupremeCourt
Over 140 petitions relating to the CAA listed today, most challenging the validity of the Act with a handful in support of the Act. Centre's plea for transfer of similar matters from His to SC is also likely to be heard #CAA #CitizenshipAmendmentAct #CAA_2019 #SupremeCourt
The Bench of CJI SA Bobde with Justices S Abdul Nazeer and Sanjiv Khanna has assembled and will begin hearing the matter shortly.
Read 32 tweets
As a part of door to door campaign to earn support for #CAA2019 The leaders of Thiruvananthapuram BJP went to the house of a man named Mohanan Nair.

Before letting them into house He asked.

Nair: Is there any Brahmin in your group?

BJP: No!

Nair: Is there any Nair(another cast) in your group?

BJP: Yes ..!
*Two raised their hands*

Nair: Only you two can come in!

BJP: *Hesitated*

Nair: Don't you hear me?

BJP: This is insulting. You can't make them sit outside just because they are not from a particular cast.

Nair: This is exactly what the #CitizenshipAmendmentAct is..! Indian constitution doesn't permit you to discriminate people in the basis of race colour or religion.

BJP: 😵😵😵


Credits: @vdsatheesan
Read 3 tweets
Decoding #ShaheenBaghStandoff . It started with AAP MLA #amanatullahkhan 's speech on December 15, 2019, following which announcements were made by loudspeakers to goad people to reach #JamiaMilia . Outsiders came there, hurled Molotov cocktails, stones on @DelhiPolice (1)
As #JamiaMilia simmered, politicians joined the game. Competitive politics between #amanatullahkhan & Congress' #AsifMohammad aggravated it. Then appeared older women & they occupied Road no 13 & both carriageways were blocked. Asif M Khan feared Amanatullah taking credit (2)
Amanatullah retreated for sometime, Asif Khan sat on Dharna & implored DCP Southeast to arrest him but he refused to play ball. #ShaheenBaghProtest kept growing with hidden hands supplying funds & food packs, tea, snacks, warm clothes, blankets were provided to protesters. (3)
Read 10 tweets
@singer_shaan Heard your comment on Know the Nation that #CAA2019 is for *persecuted *religious *minorities!! Have you not read the act itself & gave the three * words a great miss in fine print. Only in speech of our Home Minister @AmitShah Ji said so.…
Above link to read the #CitizenshipAmendmentAct carefully & take assistance of your legal counsels too. @RanvirShorey @PrahladKakar @ritesh_sid @prasoonjoshi_ @kunalkohli @vivekagnihotri @AnupamPKher

Its not about you all learned men not read but simply don't believe in hearsay
Read 3 tweets

In #Parliament, Home Minister asserted that ‘lakhs and crores’ of people will benefit from #CAA2019

We did #FactCheck and dug out some data from Questions answered in #RajyaSabha

What we found is interesting and revealing


As recently as on 8th August 2018, Ministry of Home Affairs claimed in #RajyaSabha that data on people from minority communities coming to India on ground of religious persecution from different provinces of Pakistan is not centrally maintained

Interestingly, MHA did say that issue of persecution was taken up with Govt of Pakistan and Bangladesh diplomatically.

What Pakistan and Bangladesh said can be seen in pictures below, which was reproduced in atleast 3 responses, all in 2014.
Read 17 tweets
ভাৰতীয় সংবিধানৰ 5ৰ পৰা 11 অনুচ্ছেদ নাগৰিকত্বৰ ওপৰত । 1955 চনত নাগৰিকত্ব আইন প্ৰনয়ন হয় । এই আইন বিভিন্ন কাৰণত বিভিন্ন সময়ত সংশোধন কৰিব লগীয়া হৈছে । 1986, 1992, 2003, 2005, 2015 আৰু 2019 চনত সংশোধন হয় । @TapanChangmai1 @abhinabsharma11 @himantabiswa @sarbanandsonwal
1947 চনত ভাৰত আৰু পাকিস্তান ধৰ্মৰ ভিত্তিত বিভাজন হৈছিল ।
জন্ম সূত্ৰে ভাৰত এখন হিন্দু ৰাষ্ট্ৰ । পাচত ভাৰতীয় সংবিধানত প্ৰক্তন প্ৰধানমন্ত্ৰী ইন্দিৰা গান্ধীয়ে ধৰ্ম নিৰপেক্ষ শব্দৰ সংযোজন কৰি ধৰ্ম নিৰপেক্ষ দেশ কৰে ।
#Assam #CAA2019
বিভাজনৰ সময়ত বহু সংখ্যক হিন্দু, শিখ, জৈন, বৌদ্ধ আৰু পাৰ্ছী লোক পাকিস্তানত থাকিল আৰু কিছুসংখ্যক মুছলমান ভাৰতত থাকিল । বিভাজনৰ পাচত হিন্দু আৰু অন্যান্য ধৰ্মাৱলম্বী লোকসকলৰ ওপৰত অবৰ্ণনীয় অত্যাচাৰ চলিল, বহু লোক আহি ভাৰত সোমালোহি ।
Read 37 tweets
Putting a thread to tell facts of CAA and the NRC which ARE mutually exclusive. The protests/violence is inconsequential. I will detail why.

CAA is Citizenship (Amendment) Act 2019. It applies only to those citizens of the PERSECUTED MINORITIES from the countries of Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh. It is NOT applicable to Indian Citizens.

This amendment is completely constitutional because both the houses of the Parliament of India have passed it and it has the assent of the President of India.

Read 15 tweets
(1/n) Data about the potential beneficiaries of the #CAA2019 is confusing. There doesn't seem to be any conclusive data. Here is a detailed data piece…
(2/n) The Intelligence Bureau told the 'Joint Committee on the Citizen (Amendment) Bill -2016' that there are 31313 immediate beneficiaries of CAA
(3/n)A total of 2,738 Afghani & Pakistani nationals were provided citizenship during 2016-2019, the religion they belong to is not known since online capturing of data for 6 minority communities began i only 2018
Read 12 tweets
नागरिकता संशोधन कानून पर कई तरह के भ्रम फैलाए जा रहे हैं और इस विषय पर गुमराह भी किया जा रहा है

पर #PIB आपको इस विषय से जुड़े कई अहम सवालों के जवाब से रूबरू करा रहा है जिनको लेकर आपके मन में संशय है


@HMOIndia @PrakashJavdekar @DDNewsHindi @PMOIndia #CAA2019 पर कई तरह के भ्रम फैलाए जा रहे हैं और इस विषय पर गुमराह भी किया जा रहा है

पर #PIB आपको इस विषय से जुड़े कई अहम सवालों के जवाब से रूबरू करा रहा है जिनको लेकर आपके मन में संशय है

@HMOIndia @PrakashJavdekar @DDNewsHindi @PMOIndia #CAA से तीन देशों के हिन्दू, सिख, जैन, बौद्ध, पारसी और ईसाईयों को कैसे लाभ होगा?

इसके जवाब के लिए पढ़िए #PIB सीरीज़ के सवाल और जवाब ताकि इश विषय के संबंध में कोई संशय न रहे

Read 10 tweets
Lead story now on

The cities where protests have so far not been disallowed include Mumbai, Chennai, Pune, Hyderabad, Nagpur, Bhubaneswar, Kolkata and Bhopal.…

#NDTVLeadStory #CAAProtests #CitizenshipAmendmentAct
Road No. 13A between Mathura Road and Kalindi Kunj is closed for traffic movement. People travelling from DND or Akshardham to reach Delhi: Delhi Traffic Police.

Read 107 tweets
A thread explaining the provisions pertaining to #Citizenship in India and some concerns regarding the #CAA2019:


Citizenship of India can be acquired by Birth, descent, registration, naturalisation or incorporation of territory.

Any foreigner on becoming eligible can acquire citizenship by registration or by naturalisation irrespective of his country or community.


#CAA2019 enables foreigners of 6 minority communities from 3 countries to apply for citizenship on basis of religious persecution

It does NOT amend any existing legal provision which enables any foreigner to apply for Indian citizenship through registration/naturalisation.

Read 12 tweets
Protesting in the cold rain outside the Radcliffe Camera, Oxford University.

In strong solidarity with students of #jamia and many others protesting the #CAA2019 across the country.

Here's @sameeric reading out a statement of solidarity endorsed by 400+ students and academics at the @UniofOxford

Condemning the violence meted out to fellow students.And demanding that citizens be allowed their right to protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act #CAA2019
@sameeric @UniofOxford @ucu, the Union representing academic and teaching staff at the @UniofOxford, condemns the brutal police crackdown on student protests in India.

Full statement here:…

@OxfordUCU @ArisKatzourakis @SnehaK20
Read 6 tweets
#CAAProtests #CAA2019 #ISupportCAA #JamiaProtests
A thread to CAB and NRC, as per my understanding. Feel free to educate me more :
CAA is constitutional if we talk about it separately, without taking NRC into the picture. As, it doesn’t exclude anyone from taking refuge. It’s just about the special inclusion of the persecuted minority, and giving them citizenship.
Anyone can become citizens of India by naturalisation process of 12 years. For persecuted minorities it has been reduced to 5 years. Although, the govt. still hasn't made rules how to identify minorities from three countries if they don't have any document.
Read 12 tweets
Having interviewed many grassroots activists who have organised 100s of protests with even over 10,000 people, I've learnt that takes YEARS of mobilising, conversations, leadership, to keep rallies non-violent, especially when the causes are often life & death. + #CAA2019
Twitterati condemning and giving sage advise to students to keep calm, not slap a cop when he slaps a student, probably don't recognise how HARD it is to be non-violent in the face of asymmetric power of the state. + #CAA2019
We can't forget that a student's slap is not equal to trained cops in riot gear shooting bullets, tear gas & a history of quelling protests of all kinds with cases of "kidnapping govt officials", "blocking govt work", causing nuisance etc. #CAA2019
Read 6 tweets
Clashes in New Seelampur, East Delhi. Stone pelting, tear shells fired back. Roads strewn with rocks.

#CABProtests Image
Thousands on the streets, pelting stones at police. To and fro battles. Smoke shells fired.

New Seelampur #CABProtests
#CitizenshipAmendmentBill2019 Image
Running battles still going on, right under a metro line.

Seelampur. #CABProtests #CitizenshipAmendmentBill2019
Read 8 tweets
Jamia Protests hearing to commence in Supreme Court. CJI SA Bobde and Justices BR Gavai and Suryakant to hear the matter

#CAA2019 #OperationJamia
Counsel tells the Court that with the passage of the #CAA2019 there was discontent across the country. This Act was tried to be painted as Anti Muslims and the first protest was sparked in the north east

#OperationJamia #SupremeCourt
There is a siege in Jamia and AMU and the right to peaceful protest should be upheld, Counsels to the Supreme Court

#OperationJamia #SupremeCourt
Read 43 tweets
George Orwell said, 'During times of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act'. The @BJP4India government led by Hon'ble PM Shri @narendramodi Ji has & will always stand by the truth, & only truth shall prevail.
Here is a thread on facts vs myths on the #CAA2019
Here is a thread on facts vs myths on the #CAA2019.
Here is a thread on facts vs myths on the #CAA2019.
Read 11 tweets
Protests against #CAA2019 for 18 cities/towns:

(Please mention more in the comments if we've missed any)
- Dec 16th: Ongoing | TISS Mumbai
- Dec 16th: 4PM | Mumbai University, main gate, Kalina campus
- Dec 16th: 7PM | CESA, Kurla (West)
- Dec 19th: 2PM | Ambassador Hotel
- Dec 19th: 3PM | Girgaum Chowpatty near Tilak statue
- Dec 16th: 2PM | Jantar Mantar
- Dec 16th: 5:30PM | IIT Delhi
- Dec 16th: 6PM | India Gate
- Dec 16th: Ongoing | Jamia Millia Islamia Gate 7
- Dec 16th: 7:30PM | CR Park Market no. 2
Read 12 tweets
My own position on #CAA2019 has been - it is sound in principle (read @pratimbose article👇) and nothing wrong constitutionally (as explained by none other than Harish Salve). But, I anticipate serious issues in implementation. Therefore, other than the #NorthEast #CABProtests /2
#CABPolitics e.g. in #Assam where it is a live issue (but religion agnostic as they are against all immigrants changing the demographics of the region) for the rest of India it is largely an academic issue. Therefore, #CABProtests in the name of “secularism” ill-conceived 3/n
3/n Besides, #CAA2019 has been passed by an act of Parliament and not by any Presidential Diktat. If it has to be undone - it cannot be through violence and vandalism. Those upholding the Constitutional values - must also adopt democratic means and not promote mobocracy #CAB 4/n
Read 8 tweets
Anti CAA protests: A battery of Senior Lawyers present in Courtroom 1 of the #SupremeCourt.

The matter concerning Police violence against students of Jamia Milia Islamia and Aligarh Muslim University likely to be mentioned.

Senior Advocates Indira Jaising, Colin Gonslaves, Salman Khurshid among some of the lawyers present in the Courtroom.

Senior Advocate Indira Jaising requests the Court to take suo moto cognizance of the "violence that is unleashed" on the students, including law students, across the country

Read 12 tweets

Related hashtags

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3.00/month or $30.00/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!