,
18 tweets,
10 min read
Read on Twitter
A mother and 11 children were killed in an airstrike in Afghanistan last fall. We spoke to the father who was left to search for answers. The U.S. initially said it was not involved, but after our visual investigation, it changed its story. Thread 👇
The sole survivor of the family is the father and husband: Masih Mubarez. He was working in Iran when his wife Amina called him at 4 AM from their home in Mullah Hafiz, a small hamlet in Wardak Province. American and Afghan troops were inside their house, she said. It was a raid.
Seven hours later, Amina was dead. And so were their 4 daughters and 3 sons, including Mohamed Ilyas, pictured here not far from their family house where he was pulled out of the rubble, according to witnesses. Four young cousins, staying over at their aunt, were killed too. 
Masih, who worked for four years as a teacher with @SAK_Sweden, has been looking for answers ever since. He doesn’t have enough money to rebuild his house, and currently lives in a rental apartment in Kabul. Being in the village hurts too much, he says.
Locals pointed towards American responsibility for the alleged airstrike.
But the U.S. denied it. Twice.
First, they said they could find no connection between their actions and the allegations. Later, they denied they that any strike ever took place in the district that day.
But the U.S. denied it. Twice.
First, they said they could find no connection between their actions and the allegations. Later, they denied they that any strike ever took place in the district that day.
How to verify such claims out of a remote, Taliban-controlled village where there's no internet and cell-towers are regularly shut down? Along with @TBIJ, we analyzed photos/videos, satellite images, and interviewed witnesses — all to determine who should be held accountable.
Geolocation is often the first step for verification. By matching visual clues in the footage with satellite imagery, we confirmed the exact location reported by Masih → yandex.ru/maps/?l=sat&ll… (Jaghatu District, Wardak Province, #Afghanistan). The damage is clearly visible.
Photos we obtained of twisted metal found in the rubble hold several clues, including a square pattern of 4 bolts on a tail fin — a construction only use on one type of aerial weapon: Joint Direct Attack Munition (JDAM), which make “dumb” bombs “smart” (GPS-guided).
We further corroborated this with two other pieces of debris marked with “81873” — the CAGE code of Colorado-based company Woodward, Inc. The second row of digits most likely refers to the part number (41011801 C), probably part of the mechanism that moves the JDAM tail fins.
While over 30 countries are active militarily in #Afghanistan, there are basically only two are conducting airstrikes: the Afghan government and the U.S. But the Afghan A-29s are not capable of carrying JDAMs. Which leaves us with the United States.
When we recently gave the U.S. military the precise coordinates (42SVC3796234207) of the family's home, their story changed: They now admit they struck the building. In self-defense, they say, as sniper fire was coming from there.
It wouldn’t be the first time Taliban fighters use civilians as shields against American airstrikes. But the U.S. military denies that any civilians were killed in the airstrike. However, the family’s corpses showed injuries consistent with the effects of an explosive blast.
The dichotomy between Masih’s claims — that 12 family members killed — and the matter-of-fact denial from the U.S. military are emblematic of the nearly 18-year-old war, where civilians in nearly every corner of #Afghanistan have been touched by violence and death by both sides.
“We're not perfect guys, but we are the good guys,” former Defense Sec. Mattis said about avoiding civilian casualties. But the Pentagon released a report in 2018 highlighting concerns about how the military investigates and responds to incidents. jcs.mil/Portals/36/Doc…
(An aspect not included in the story, but symbolic to the incident, is that Masih told us that there are still severely damaged houses in and around Mullah Hafiz. Not damaged by the 2001 U.S.-led invasion of Afghanistan, but during the Soviet-Afghan War from 1979 to 1989.)
This @nytimes visual investigation started when @JessicaPurkiss reached out with a geolocation request. We (@bottidavid @malachybrowne) teamed up with @TBIJ, and @FahimAbed and @tmgneff in Kabul. Also h/t to @Brian_Castner and @johnismay. nytimes.com/2019/06/03/wor…
And here's the accompanying article of @JessicaPurkiss on @TBIJ. thebureauinvestigates.com/stories/2019-0…
Do you have a 📷📹 that you think we (@nytimes visual investigations) should investigate? Suggestions, ideas, tips? Feel free to reach out via DM or email (christiaan.triebert@nytimes.com) — also for more secure ways of communication. Watch our work here: youtube.com/playlist?list=…
