, 101 tweets, 11 min read Read on Twitter
(THREAD) BREAKING: A recent revelation sheds new light on the Trump-Russia timeline—particularly the relationship Flynn had with the Trumps.
1/ Flynn first met Trump in mid-2015. Flynn says they hit it off quickly and were of a similar mind on foreign policy and national security.
2/ Yet in late March 2016—more than six months later—Flynn's name was nowhere to be found on Trump's foreign policy/national security team.
3/ On March 21, 2016, Trump named for the NYT six members of a team he variously called his "foreign policy" and "national security" team.
4/ Flynn, who became Trump's National Security Advisor and was said to be his top advisor on the subject during the campaign, wasn't listed.
5/ But on March 21, 2016, Trump told the NYT he had "quite a few more" advisors on the subject of national security besides those he named.
6/ So on March 26, 2016—5 days later—he named three more members of his national security team. Mike Flynn's name still wasn't on the list.
7/ On March 31, Trump held the first meeting of his national security team. A photo from that day shows even more new people had been added.
8/ Yet even by March 31, with a dozen members of Trump's foreign policy/national security team revealed, Flynn's name and face were absent.
9/ Two items must be noted here: first, Carter Page, named by Trump on March 21, was inexplicably absent from the team at its first meeting.
10/ This matters because we now know the team was just then beginning to discuss whether to send a private citizen to meet with the Kremlin.
11/ Papadopoulos—named to the team and pictured on March 31—said he had contacts at the Kremlin who wanted to meet soon with Trump's aides.
12/ The most likely member of the team for the task was Page, as he traveled often to Moscow for conferences. And indeed he did that July.
13/ So Page suddenly disappearing from public relations materials for the foreign policy/national security team at that moment is notable.
14/ A second item to note here: Flynn had already traveled to Moscow to have dinner with Vladimir Putin by the time Trump named his team.
15/ Flynn dined with Putin at an RT gala in December 2015, and admits to talking presidential politics—and no one doubts he told Trump this.
16/ Why is that? Because Trump was obsessed with Putin, and he was in regular contact with Flynn on issues—Russia included—by December 2015.
17/ So keep in mind, when you look at the public roster—particularly photos—of Trump's foreign policy/national security team, who is absent.
18/ We have to presume Trump had input into who would be on his team—and also who would be publicly named. And publicly pictured. Note that.
19/ In September '16, WaPo reported Trump had added even more members to his foreign policy/national security team between March and August.
20/ Yet even as his foreign policy/national security team swelled beyond 12 members—already sizable—Flynn wasn't any part of that operation.
21/ It's extraordinary that Trump had 15 or more advisors on national security he was willing to name and brag about and not one became NSA.
22/ The reason for this is Trump, during his run, had a Shadow Cabinet—advisors he knew weren't palatable enough to be seen by the public.
23/ The Intercept says Erik Prince, who used Russian deza on Breitbart just before Election Day, was Shadow Cabinet. theintercept.com/2017/01/17/not…
24/ Prince's "deza" (Russian disinfo) was about Clinton misconduct. Absent from any Trump photos, he ended up at Trump's Election Day party.
25/ Reporting from The Washington Post from last September suggests that Mike Flynn was also in this Shadow Cabinet. washingtonpost.com/news/josh-rogi…
26/ Indeed, Trump's giant-sized foreign policy/national security shop collapsed in August of 2016 because he wouldn't pay them—or use them.
27/ The only way a POTUS nominee with *no foreign policy/national security knowledge* can dump his whole team is if he has a Shadow Cabinet.
28/ Despite having a domestic policy team, too, Trump chose Sean Hannity for his Shadow Cabinet on domestic policy. nytimes.com/2016/08/22/bus…
29/ Neither Hannity nor Trump acknowledged Hannity's role because—like Prince and Flynn—Hannity would not be a publicly palatable advisor.
30/ The reason wasn't Hannity's far-right views, but that it's unethical for a self-described journalist to secretly advise a POTUS nominee.
31/ So investigators must—likely have—observed this pattern: Trump named advisors the public could see, then relied on unpalatable figures.
32/ This is critical from a legal standpoint—as it establishes that Trump had sufficient knowledge about these figures' issues to hide them.
33/ So this is the part of the Flynn story in which we begin speaking, of all people, about Chris Christie: Trump's true "forgotten man."
34/ The New Yorker reported this week that it was a tossup whether Pence or Christie would get the VP nod. Trump preferred his pal—Christie.
35/ Ivanka and Jared, who figure significantly in this thread, pushed for Pence. Jared hated Christie. Here's why: cnn.com/2016/11/16/pol…
36/ Kushner hated Christie because Christie prosecuted Kushner's dad—but you could also say Jared knew Christie prosecuted corrupt Kushners.
37/ As Jared's questionably legal activities take center stage, consider his unwillingness to have Christie catch *another* corrupt Kushner.
38/ When Trump picked Pence—due, The New Yorker implies, to Christie's weight (Trump on Pence: "VP central casting")—Christie got screwed.
39/ But for his early loyalty, Trump rewarded Christie with a key position: head of the transition team. Christie could form the government.
40/ Christie lasted just 72 hours in the role. Despite it being his consolation prize for losing VP, Ivanka and Jared forced him out ASAP.
41/ What The New Yorker added this week (h/t @justinhendrix) is the reason Ivanka/Jared were able to get Christie off Team Trump so quickly.
42/ According to The New Yorker, what did in Chris Christie on Team Trump was his strong opposition to Mike Flynn. newyorker.com/magazine/2017/…
43/ By November 11, Christie somehow already knew about Flynn's secret (and illegal) advocacy for Turkey—suggesting he'd known pre-election.
44/ No one thinks—or says—Chris Christie learned about Flynn's complex backstory in his first 72 hours as Trump's transition-team director.
45/ What Christie knew is that Flynn was on the Shadow Cabinet—and advising Trump on some of the same issues (NatSec) Christie had hoped to.
46/ But Flynn had a huge advantage on Christie. Was it that Trump liked him more? Knew him better? Thought him smarter than Christie? No—no.
47/ Flynn's advantage—actually two advantages—is he'd already made contact with the Russians and was willing to engage in illicit behavior.
48/ So what The New Yorker describes happening in Trump Tower on November 11th is *extraordinary*. Ivanka and Jared usurped the transition.
49/ What they did was this: declared that the shadiest member of the Shadow Cabinet could have any job he wanted in Trump's administration.
50/ Ivanka made clear Flynn would be considered for Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense, National Security Advisor, or other top roles.
51/ Consider—pre-election, all the Trumps knew Flynn had to be off-radar. And they knew exactly why. Yet Ivanka ousted Christie using Flynn.
52/ It was effective because Christie—a law-and-order guy—would never accept Flynn. Which is exactly why Christie was wrong for Team Trump.
53/ It's *astonishing* Trump took *well under a day* to choose Flynn over the man *he'd wanted for Vice President*—a close personal friend.
54/ Why was Flynn *so* valuable to Trump he could have any job, get Christie kicked out of the administration, get Ivanka directly involved?
55/ Asked another way, when Ivanka said to Christie Flynn was to be rewarded for "loyalty" to the family—what did that mean? What did he do?
56/ Yesterday, CNN gave us a lot more info on exactly what Flynn might have been doing—secretly—during the campaign. cnn.com/2017/10/16/pol…
57/ Just as Page had to disappear from the campaign in order to go to Moscow and meet with Kremlin allies—as the IC says he did—thus Flynn.
58/ Don "loved" the idea of Hillary dirt—enough to bring Kushner and his dad's campaign manager to meet Kremlin agents *in his dad's house*.
59/ Don (Jr.) knew what his dad wanted—Hillary dirt—both from private conversations, it's quite clear, and also his dad's public statements.
60/ CNN now reports Flynn was Trump's contact for a much *larger* effort to get Hillary dirt via suspected Russian agents on the "dark web."
61/ Isn't it likely Ivanka was willing to go to bat in such extraordinary fashion for Flynn's "loyalty" because she knew about such efforts?
62/ Don't worry—this isn't mere speculation. We can look at the Trump-Russia timeline to *prove* Ivanka and Jared liked Flynn due to Russia.
63/ The earliest Flynn could officially have been locked in as a Trump White House staffer was November 12, 2016—the day Christie was fired.
64/ Now consider Flynn's activities with Jared in the four weeks following this earliest date for his elevation to Trump's permanent staff.
65/ As the Rosneft oil deal—Russia's largest ever—closed the first week of December, Flynn was with Jared and Bud McFarlane at Trump Tower.
66/ McFarlane—an Iran-Contra villain the FBI looked at for secret contacts with our geopolitical enemies—is a Russian oil-pipeline advocate.
67/ Immediately thereafter, Kushner—and Flynn—were at Trump Tower with Russia's ambassador discussing building a secret Kremlin backchannel.
68/ Who was the Kremlin backchannel Kushner wanted *for*? Why—for Mike Flynn, of course! So says the New York Times: nytimes.com/2017/05/26/us/…
69/ Reuters has reported Kushner had an unreported—and still denied—phone call with Kislyak in November. Presumably to set up this meeting.
70/ We know Kushner never reported—and still denies—the call, and that he lied on federal forms about whether the December meeting happened.
71/ Yet Kushner *must* have moved to set up that call—and that backchannel—the *moment* Flynn joined Team Trump. The timeline assures that.
72/ Flynn *couldn't* be the backchannel contact unless he was on Trump's White House staff. And he wasn't until—at the earliest—November 12.
73/ So there are two possibilities: (a) Ivanka and Kushner planned to use Flynn as their Russian liaison when they ousted Christie on 11/11;
74/ (b) Ivanka and Kushner were rewarding Flynn for other conduct—but upon hire they moved *quickly* to get him back in contact with Russia.
75/ In either case, it's clear that Flynn—and Russia—were at the heart of Ivanka and Kushner's usurpation of Trump's entire transition team.
76/ It would be fair to say that a) Ivanka is now a *major* Trump-Russia witness, and b) the governing issue of the transition was *Russia*.
77/ But we also must conclude, due to Trump's pattern of conduct, that he knew Flynn was critical to his plans—more than Christie—early on.
78/ But we must further conclude—given Flynn being *so critical* to Trump but also *so expertly and carefully hidden by him*—something else.
79/ Trump's realization Flynn had to be in the Shadow Cabinet—not out front—came after August 2015 but before March 2016. Say December 2015?
80/ December of 2015 is when Flynn met with Putin in Moscow at an RT gala and discussed presidential politics—and hit it off with Vladimir.
81/ Certainly, we know using Flynn to create a backchannel to Russia is the *first and most significant thing* the Trumps wanted Flynn for.
82/ We know Flynn's Russia-based value to Trump far exceeded *any* loyalty Trump had to Christie—and Trump *is* loyal to those loyal to him.
83/ And we know that just after meeting Kislyak with Flynn, Kushner secretly met with Putin's banker—lying about this on federal forms, too.
84/ So Kushner puts Flynn at the center of a plot to create a permanent Kremlin backchannel right as he's meeting with Putin's state banker.
85/ But Ivanka—whose family finances are of course also Jared's—takes the lead in de facto firing Christie so Kushner doesn't look vengeful.
86/ So the New Yorker piece—added to the rest of the Trump-Russia timeline—dramatically changes how we think of the Trump-Flynn connection.
87/ It also underscores that Flynn was doing something behind the scenes—after December 2015—that merited some *extraordinary* compensation.
88/ The idea a disgraced ex-government official should be looked at by Ivanka and Jared for Secretary of State? Defense? He was clearly key.
89/ And the timing of Trump hiding him—and Kushner using him to connect with top Kremlin aides—tells us just how the Trumps saw him as key.
90/ So no one can doubt, on these facts, that Trump—despite claims to the contrary—*did know* Flynn was talking to Russia in December 2016.
91/ Indeed—Flynn's unique role in "talking to Russia" was likely *exactly* the reason Trump kept him *off* his NatSec team in March of 2016.
92/ To investigators, these connected facts—especially facts connecting, and behaviors that track, over such a long time—suggest conspiracy.
93/ Action-steps—Mueller must interview Ivanka as though she were a *major* Trump-Russia witness. Because based on this TNY article, she is.
94/ Media must use factual narratives like this to try to determine Trump's level of *knowledge* at all points in the Trump-Russia timeline.
95/ The public must *not* forget Mike Flynn simply because he's out of the limelight and almost certain to be charged with FARA violations.
96/ Journalists must be better than The New Yorker was about seeing the whole field of data on Trump and Russia—and thus not burying ledes.
97/ Investigators must not—though I doubt they are—credit Kushner's repeated claims about forgetting to do things (always involving Russia).
98/ Team Trump's Kremlin-backchannel efforts *must not be seen* as a post-election phenomenon. Flynn was being positioned for this early on.
99/ Trump's foreign policy/national security team—unused, unpaid, but also containing a key Papadopoulos/Page link—must be more scrutinized.
100/ Every fact we have points to a Trump family conspiracy on Russia—the *whole family*. There are no exculpatory facts—so BEAR DOWN. {end}
Missing some Tweet in this thread?
You can try to force a refresh.

Like this thread? Get email updates or save it to PDF!

Subscribe to Seth Abramson
Profile picture

Get real-time email alerts when new unrolls are available from this author!

This content may be removed anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just three indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member and get exclusive features!

Premium member ($3.00/month or $30.00/year)

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!